{
    "schemaVersion": 1,
    "generatedAt": "2026-11-20T17:11:49+00:00",
    "engine": "aisc-360-22-beam-3",
    "referenceFingerprints": {
        "tools/lib/aisc-verification.php": "3c5dfcdf1ea6dda0ca91e396bd8a8c92e40cfe1abc48f2c02846dee268b1c4f1",
        "tests/fixtures/aisc-design-sections.json": "c1f7d64689a164fe977f3e42846b55d9087a6b630ea370781203d3086a35d762",
        "tests/fixtures/aisc-family-sections.json": "8868eac47ee70088e4ab5f01202845b87751739933324085448f46f319d07136",
        "tests/fixtures/aisc-published-benchmarks.json": "b086121a18034499c59beeedcf9034997f13205987a967f5781bed6ff4c2172d",
        "tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py": "b51813600f6967b46131f19a554b0fdde2237053a29ffe7a9c3c7df39b101591",
        "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json": "64db66e73dd0affa47a32533cfeb1a6ec1fd50344ce725b1a942b5a0f46f9c35"
    },
    "fingerprints": {
        "core/functions/aisc-design.php": "3fccb6eb69984b786fd98f4e6ac387cd35f3667030aa2f6198f20699469198f1",
        "core/functions/aisc-hss.php": "d0fd0c93c4ad9634747dd41da39b37343adeb2e55aeff96621a5464d522e40e5",
        "core/functions/aisc-section-families.php": "ac19560fe03162d4c391d8f09acddfd0068a9792b501497272e973d40b952d4e",
        "core/functions/design-calculations.php": "b81d83a052e41f69422f8d30f853560735c288181d587934010f8136800bef46",
        "core/functions/beam-design-demand.php": "31de93c33e5e1db6e73a381c231fd69da8cdb7e36d78db97ac307047158f6e72"
    },
    "summary": {
        "status": "passed",
        "totalCases": 41,
        "passedCases": 41,
        "totalChecks": 116,
        "passedChecks": 116
    },
    "cases": [
        {
            "id": "AISC-F2-YIELD",
            "title": "Compact section · yielding",
            "section": "W18X50",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "B4.1b",
                "F1",
                "F2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 421,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 420.8333333333333,
                    "difference": 0.16666666666668561,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 379,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 378.75,
                    "difference": 0.25,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 252,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 251.99600798403196,
                    "difference": 0.0039920159680377765,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.1-1B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.01-1B-w-shape-continuously-braced-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Nominal and available flexural strength"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 18,
                "bf": 7.5,
                "tw": 0.355,
                "tf": 0.57,
                "kdes": 0.972,
                "Sx": 88.9,
                "Zx": 101,
                "ry": 1.65,
                "rts": 1.98,
                "ho": 17.4,
                "J": 1.24,
                "Ix": 800,
                "A": 14.7,
                "W": 50
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-F2-INELASTIC",
            "title": "Inelastic lateral-torsional buckling",
            "section": "W18X50",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 140,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-2",
                "F2-5",
                "F2-6"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values normalized to Cb = 1",
            "notes": "The source uses Cb > 1. Its uncapped LTB strength is divided by Cb from the printed quarter-point moments. Available strengths then use F1 factors. The 0.2% tolerance accommodates rounded properties and the source E = 29,007.5 ksi versus our 29,000 ksi. This does not verify a variable-Cb implementation.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 336.1253805134364,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "Published Mn divided by source Cb",
                    "publishedValue": 341.59,
                    "actual": 335.99685383006755,
                    "difference": 0.12852668336887518,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.6722507610268729,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 302.5128424620928,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "0.90 × normalized published Mn",
                    "publishedValue": 341.59,
                    "actual": 302.39716844706084,
                    "difference": 0.11567401503197061,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.6050256849241856,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 201.2726829421775,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "Normalized published Mn / 1.67",
                    "publishedValue": 341.59,
                    "actual": 201.19572085632788,
                    "difference": 0.0769620858496296,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.402545365884355,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "normalization": {
                "type": "uncapped-ltb-cb1",
                "publishedNominalKipFt": 341.59,
                "quarterPointMomentsKipFt": [
                    266.44,
                    257.56,
                    266.44,
                    257.56
                ],
                "sourceCb": 1.0162576818156852,
                "expression": "Cb = 12.5 Mmax / (2.5 Mmax + 3 MA + 4 MB + 3 MC); reference Mn = published Mn / Cb"
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "SCIA AISC 360-22 — F.1-2B",
                "url": "https://help.scia.net/26.0/en/steel/code_checks_inc_fire_resistance/tb_steel_uls/aisc/benchmarks_aisc_360/files/aisc_360_22_bending_example_f_1_2b.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22",
                "location": "Page 2: quarter-point moments and nominal LTB resistance"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 18,
                "bf": 7.5,
                "tw": 0.355,
                "tf": 0.57,
                "kdes": 0.972,
                "Sx": 88.9,
                "Zx": 101,
                "ry": 1.65,
                "rts": 1.98,
                "ho": 17.4,
                "J": 1.24,
                "Ix": 800,
                "A": 14.7,
                "W": 50
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-F2-ELASTIC",
            "title": "Elastic lateral-torsional buckling",
            "section": "W18X50",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 210,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-3 / F2-4",
                "F2-5",
                "F2-6"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values normalized to Cb = 1",
            "notes": "The source uses Cb > 1. Its uncapped LTB strength is divided by Cb from the printed quarter-point moments. Available strengths then use F1 factors. The 0.2% tolerance accommodates rounded properties and the source E = 29,007.5 ksi versus our 29,000 ksi. This does not verify a variable-Cb implementation.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 246.2753027473352,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "Published Mn divided by source Cb",
                    "publishedValue": 322.69,
                    "actual": 246.015465111429,
                    "difference": 0.25983763590619446,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.4925506054946704,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 221.64777247260167,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "0.90 × normalized published Mn",
                    "publishedValue": 322.69,
                    "actual": 221.4139186002861,
                    "difference": 0.23385387231556365,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.44329554494520335,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 147.47024116606897,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.002,
                    "basis": "Normalized published Mn / 1.67",
                    "publishedValue": 322.69,
                    "actual": 147.31464976732278,
                    "difference": 0.15559139874619632,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.29494048233213793,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "normalization": {
                "type": "uncapped-ltb-cb1",
                "publishedNominalKipFt": 322.69,
                "quarterPointMomentsKipFt": [
                    266.44,
                    114.57,
                    197.16,
                    247.79
                ],
                "sourceCb": 1.310281609240623,
                "expression": "Cb = 12.5 Mmax / (2.5 Mmax + 3 MA + 4 MB + 3 MC); reference Mn = published Mn / Cb"
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "SCIA AISC 360-22 — F.1-3B",
                "url": "https://help.scia.net/26.0/en/steel/code_checks_inc_fire_resistance/tb_steel_uls/aisc/benchmarks_aisc_360/files/aisc_360_22_bending_example_f_1_3b.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22",
                "location": "Page 2: quarter-point moments and nominal LTB resistance"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 18,
                "bf": 7.5,
                "tw": 0.355,
                "tf": 0.57,
                "kdes": 0.972,
                "Sx": 88.9,
                "Zx": 101,
                "ry": 1.65,
                "rts": 1.98,
                "ho": 17.4,
                "J": 1.24,
                "Ix": 800,
                "A": 14.7,
                "W": 50
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-F3-NONCOMPACT",
            "title": "Noncompact flange · local buckling",
            "section": "W21X48",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "B4.1b",
                "F1",
                "F3-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 442,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 442.16776994328393,
                    "difference": 0.16776994328392902,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 398,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 397.9509929489555,
                    "difference": 0.049007051044497985,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 265,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 264.7711197265173,
                    "difference": 0.22888027348267315,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "properties": {
                "d": 20.6,
                "bf": 8.14,
                "tw": 0.35,
                "tf": 0.43,
                "kdes": 0.93,
                "Sx": 93,
                "Zx": 107,
                "ry": 1.66,
                "rts": 2.05,
                "ho": 20.2,
                "J": 0.803,
                "Ix": 959,
                "A": 14.1,
                "W": 48
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.3B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.03B-w-shape-noncompact-flanges-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Flange classification and F3-1 resistance"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-G2-ROLLED",
            "title": "Shear · special rolled-shape factors",
            "section": "W24X62",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-2",
                "G2.1(a)"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web area",
                    "field": "shear.Aw",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 10.2,
                    "unit": "in²",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 10.190999999999999,
                    "difference": 0.009000000000000341,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 306,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 305.73,
                    "difference": 0.2699999999999818,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 306,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 305.73,
                    "difference": 0.2699999999999818,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 204,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 203.82000000000002,
                    "difference": 0.1799999999999784,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Shear coefficient Cv1",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 1,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 1,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 G.1B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/G.01B-w-shape-major-axis-shear-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Web area, nominal shear and LRFD/ASD strengths"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 23.7,
                "bf": 7.04,
                "tw": 0.43,
                "tf": 0.59,
                "kdes": 1.09,
                "Sx": 131,
                "Zx": 153,
                "ry": 1.38,
                "rts": 1.75,
                "ho": 23.1,
                "J": 1.71,
                "Ix": 1550,
                "A": 18.2,
                "W": 62
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-G2-ORDINARY",
            "title": "Shear · ordinary resistance factors",
            "section": "W24X55",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-3",
                "G2.1(b)"
            ],
            "comparison": "Earlier-edition published shear values",
            "notes": "Only the unperforated steel-web baseline is compared: Fy = 50 ksi, d = 23.6 in, tw = 0.395 in and phiV = 0.90. Composite bending and web-opening design in the paper are not supported or verified. ASD = Vn / 1.67 is covered by code-factor and boundary tests, not a published ASD value in this source.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal web shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 280,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 279.66,
                    "difference": 0.339999999999975,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 252,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 251.69400000000002,
                    "difference": 0.3059999999999832,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Veríssimo, Fakury & Ribeiro — Engineering Journal, 2006",
                "url": "https://ej.aisc.org/index.php/engj/article/download/1293/1292/1292",
                "edition": "Earlier LRFD edition (1999); matching unperforated-web shear calculation only",
                "location": "Printed pp. 166–167, Example 2: baseline shear strength before openings"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 23.6,
                "bf": 7.01,
                "tw": 0.395,
                "tf": 0.505,
                "kdes": 1.01,
                "Sx": 114,
                "Zx": 134,
                "ry": 1.34,
                "rts": 1.72,
                "ho": 23.1,
                "J": 1.18,
                "Ix": 1350,
                "A": 16.2,
                "W": 55
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-SERVICE",
            "title": "Service load · deflection criterion",
            "section": "W18X50",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "Elastic beam integration",
                "Project L/360 criterion"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published demand and service criterion",
            "notes": "The published required Ix = 746 in⁴ uses the rounded 1.17 in limit. Exact L/360 gives 748.46444 in⁴; the 3 in⁴ tolerance records that rounding difference. Required Ix is derived from the actual integrated deflection, not a second beam formula. Equilibrium reactions for this simple span are supplied analytically; this case verifies integration and the criterion, not the external solver or all support arrangements.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD required moment",
                    "field": "service.lrfdMoment",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 266,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 266.43750000000006,
                    "difference": 0.43750000000005684,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD required moment",
                    "field": "service.asdMoment",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 184,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 183.75,
                    "difference": 0.25,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Live deflection limit",
                    "field": "service.limit",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 1.17,
                    "unit": "in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.005,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 1.1666666666666667,
                    "difference": 0.0033333333333331883,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.005,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Required moment of inertia",
                    "field": "service.requiredI",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 746,
                    "unit": "in⁴",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 3,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published rounded L/360 criterion",
                    "actual": 748.4644396551724,
                    "difference": 2.4644396551724412,
                    "allowedDifference": 3,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "kind": "service",
            "beam": {
                "lengthIn": 420,
                "deadKipPerFt": 0.45,
                "liveKipPerFt": 0.75,
                "Eksi": 29000,
                "denominator": 360
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.1-1A — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.01-1A-w-shape-beam-continuously-braced.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "35-ft span: required moments and live-load deflection criterion"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 18,
                "bf": 7.5,
                "tw": 0.355,
                "tf": 0.57,
                "kdes": 0.972,
                "Sx": 88.9,
                "Zx": 101,
                "ry": 1.65,
                "rts": 1.98,
                "ho": 17.4,
                "J": 1.24,
                "Ix": 800,
                "A": 14.7,
                "W": 50
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "SEGUI-A572-YIELD",
            "title": "Yielding · A572 Grade 50",
            "section": "W14X68",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values · earlier edition",
            "notes": "Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.",
            "properties": {
                "d": 14,
                "bf": 10,
                "tw": 0.415,
                "tf": 0.72,
                "kdes": 1.31,
                "Sx": 103,
                "Zx": 115,
                "ry": 2.46,
                "rts": 2.8,
                "ho": 13.3,
                "J": 3.01,
                "Ix": 722,
                "A": 20,
                "W": 68
            },
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 479.2,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 479.1666666666667,
                    "difference": 0.03333333333330302,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 431,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 431.25,
                    "difference": 0.25,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4",
                "url": "https://iunajaf.edu.iq/Gradual/Publicationoflectures/uploadsPdf/05.pdf%20-%202023.04.16%20-%2010.27.13am.pdf",
                "edition": "2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared",
                "location": "Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "SEGUI-A572-INELASTIC",
            "title": "Inelastic lateral-torsional buckling · A572 Grade 50",
            "section": "W14X68",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 240,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-2"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values · earlier edition",
            "notes": "Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.",
            "properties": {
                "d": 14,
                "bf": 10,
                "tw": 0.415,
                "tf": 0.72,
                "kdes": 1.31,
                "Sx": 103,
                "Zx": 115,
                "ry": 2.46,
                "rts": 2.8,
                "ho": 13.3,
                "J": 3.01,
                "Ix": 722,
                "A": 20,
                "W": 68
            },
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 381,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 380.9305916866171,
                    "difference": 0.069408313382894,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 343,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 342.8375325179554,
                    "difference": 0.16246748204457617,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4",
                "url": "https://iunajaf.edu.iq/Gradual/Publicationoflectures/uploadsPdf/05.pdf%20-%202023.04.16%20-%2010.27.13am.pdf",
                "edition": "2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared",
                "location": "Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "SEGUI-A572-ELASTIC",
            "title": "Elastic lateral-torsional buckling · A572 Grade 50",
            "section": "W14X68",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 360,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-3 / F2-4"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values · earlier edition",
            "notes": "Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.",
            "properties": {
                "d": 14,
                "bf": 10,
                "tw": 0.415,
                "tf": 0.72,
                "kdes": 1.31,
                "Sx": 103,
                "Zx": 115,
                "ry": 2.46,
                "rts": 2.8,
                "ho": 13.3,
                "J": 3.01,
                "Ix": 722,
                "A": 20,
                "W": 68
            },
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 291,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 290.9642201466176,
                    "difference": 0.03577985338239387,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 262,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 261.86779813195585,
                    "difference": 0.1322018680441488,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4",
                "url": "https://iunajaf.edu.iq/Gradual/Publicationoflectures/uploadsPdf/05.pdf%20-%202023.04.16%20-%2010.27.13am.pdf",
                "edition": "2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared",
                "location": "Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "HANDBOOK-A36-YIELD",
            "title": "Yielding · A36",
            "section": "W8X28",
            "grade": "A36",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 72,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published value · earlier edition",
            "notes": "Compares only the published major-axis plastic flexural resistance at Lb = 6 ft. The source also checks tension–bending interaction and other orientations; those checks are not included here. The earlier-edition reference uses the same 0.90 Fy Zx resistance.",
            "properties": {
                "d": 8.06,
                "bf": 6.54,
                "tw": 0.285,
                "tf": 0.465,
                "kdes": 0.859,
                "Sx": 24.3,
                "Zx": 27.2,
                "ry": 1.62,
                "rts": 1.84,
                "ho": 7.6,
                "J": 0.537,
                "Ix": 98,
                "A": 8.25,
                "W": 28
            },
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 73.4,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 73.44,
                    "difference": 0.03999999999999204,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Standard Handbook of Engineering Calculations · McGraw-Hill, 2004",
                "url": "https://www.mongroupsydney1.com/1.pdf",
                "edition": "Earlier AISC LRFD edition; matching major-axis plastic strength only",
                "location": "Printed p. 1.58 (PDF p. 59), W8×28 strong-axis flexural strength; procedure by Abraham J. Rokach"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A36",
                "Fy": 36,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "family": "W",
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-C-YIELD",
            "title": "Channel · yielding",
            "section": "C15X33.9",
            "family": "C",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 212,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 211.66666666666666,
                    "difference": 0.3333333333333428,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 191,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 190.5,
                    "difference": 0.5,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 127,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 126.74650698602795,
                    "difference": 0.25349301397204727,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.2-1B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.02-1B-compact-channel-continuously-braced-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 15,
                "bf": 3.4,
                "tw": 0.4,
                "tf": 0.65,
                "kdes": 1.44,
                "Sx": 42,
                "Zx": 50.8,
                "ry": 0.901,
                "rts": 1.13,
                "ho": 14.4,
                "J": 1.01,
                "Ix": 315,
                "A": 10,
                "W": 33.9,
                "Iy": 8.07,
                "Cw": 358,
                "h_tw": 30.9
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-C-LTB",
            "title": "Channel · inelastic buckling",
            "section": "C15X33.9",
            "family": "C",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 60,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-2",
                "F2-5",
                "F2-6",
                "F2-8b"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "The source rounds limiting lengths and intermediate moments. A 0.5% strength tolerance retains those published values.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 192,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.005,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 191.47033415825967,
                    "difference": 0.529665841740325,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.96,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 173,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.005,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 172.32330074243373,
                    "difference": 0.6766992575662698,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.865,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 115,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0.005,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 114.65289470554472,
                    "difference": 0.34710529445527527,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5750000000000001,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lp",
                    "field": "bending.Lp",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 3.18,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.01,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 3.182513169877612,
                    "difference": 0.002513169877611965,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.01,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lr",
                    "field": "bending.Lr",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 11.2,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.06,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 11.20670480393395,
                    "difference": 0.006704803933951453,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.06,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.2-2B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.02-2B-compact-channel-braced-at-fifth-points-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 15,
                "bf": 3.4,
                "tw": 0.4,
                "tf": 0.65,
                "kdes": 1.44,
                "Sx": 42,
                "Zx": 50.8,
                "ry": 0.901,
                "rts": 1.13,
                "ho": 14.4,
                "J": 1.01,
                "Ix": 315,
                "A": 10,
                "W": 33.9,
                "Iy": 8.07,
                "Cw": 358,
                "h_tw": 30.9
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-C-SHEAR",
            "title": "Channel · shear factors",
            "section": "C15X33.9",
            "family": "C",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2.1(b)"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 180,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 180,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 162,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 162,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 108,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 107.78443113772455,
                    "difference": 0.2155688622754468,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 G.2B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/G.02B-channel-major-axis-shear-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 15,
                "bf": 3.4,
                "tw": 0.4,
                "tf": 0.65,
                "kdes": 1.44,
                "Sx": 42,
                "Zx": 50.8,
                "ry": 0.901,
                "rts": 1.13,
                "ho": 14.4,
                "J": 1.01,
                "Ix": 315,
                "A": 10,
                "W": 33.9,
                "Iy": 8.07,
                "Cw": 358,
                "h_tw": 30.9
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-SQUARE-SERVICE",
            "title": "Square HSS · strength and serviceability",
            "section": "HSS3-1/2X3-1/2X1/8",
            "family": "HSS-SQUARE",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F7-1",
                "F7-2"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "At the published design thickness, b/t lies just above the compact limit. The engine includes the small noncompact-flange reduction reflected in the published table strengths. Square HSS has no lateral-torsional buckling check.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 7.2,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.01,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 7.207583983909703,
                    "difference": 0.007583983909702496,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.01,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 4.79,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.01,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 4.795465059154826,
                    "difference": 0.00546505915482598,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.01,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Required Ix",
                    "field": "service.requiredI",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 2.85,
                    "unit": "in^4",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.005,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 2.8476562499999996,
                    "difference": 0.002343750000000533,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.005,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Live deflection limit",
                    "field": "service.limit",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.375,
                    "unit": "in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.0005,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 0.375,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.0005,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "kind": "service",
            "beam": {
                "lengthIn": 90,
                "deadKipPerFt": 0.145,
                "liveKipPerFt": 0.435,
                "Eksi": 29000,
                "denominator": 240
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.6 — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.06-square-hss-compact-flanges.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 3.5,
                "bf": 3.5,
                "tdes": 0.116,
                "tnom": 0.125,
                "Sx": 1.66,
                "Zx": 1.93,
                "ry": 1.37,
                "J": 4.58,
                "Ix": 2.9,
                "A": 1.54,
                "W": 5.61
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-NONCOMPACT",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · noncompact flange",
            "section": "HSS10X6X3/16",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 252,
            "clauses": [
                "F7-2",
                "F7-10",
                "F7-11"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "The source uses Cb = 1.14; the engine uses Cb = 1. Local buckling governs in both. This comparison verifies the governing strength, not the source’s Cb-enhanced LTB value.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 66.3,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 66.36196078868015,
                    "difference": 0.0619607886801532,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 59.7,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 59.72576470981215,
                    "difference": 0.02576470981214385,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 39.7,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 39.73770107106596,
                    "difference": 0.037701071065960434,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lp",
                    "field": "bending.Lp",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 210,
                    "unit": "in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published limiting length",
                    "actual": 210.1428922700361,
                    "difference": 0.14289227003609994,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lr",
                    "field": "bending.Lr",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 5580,
                    "unit": "in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published limiting length",
                    "actual": 5579.426301144111,
                    "difference": 0.5736988558892335,
                    "allowedDifference": 5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.7B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.07B-rect-hss-noncompact-flanges-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 10,
                "bf": 6,
                "tdes": 0.174,
                "tnom": 0.1875,
                "Sx": 14.9,
                "Zx": 18,
                "ry": 2.52,
                "J": 73.8,
                "Ix": 74.6,
                "A": 5.37,
                "W": 19.63
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-SLENDER",
            "title": "Square HSS · slender flange",
            "section": "HSS8X8X3/16",
            "family": "HSS-SQUARE",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F7-3",
                "F7-4"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Uses the Companion’s conservative effective section with ineffective strips removed from both flanges. It deliberately does not claim the higher capacity obtained by shifting the neutral axis.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 50.4,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 50.30726180412691,
                    "difference": 0.09273819587308907,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 45.4,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 45.27653562371422,
                    "difference": 0.12346437628578144,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 30.2,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 30.124108864746656,
                    "difference": 0.07589113525334312,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.8B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.08B-square-hss-slender-flanges-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 8,
                "bf": 8,
                "tdes": 0.174,
                "tnom": 0.1875,
                "Sx": 13.6,
                "Zx": 15.7,
                "ry": 3.18,
                "J": 84.5,
                "Ix": 54.4,
                "A": 5.37,
                "W": 19.63
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "slender",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Slender flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-PIPE-YIELD",
            "title": "Pipe · yielding",
            "section": "Pipe8XS",
            "family": "PIPE",
            "grade": "A53-B",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F8-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Flexure only is compared. The unused shear calculation takes Lv = 240 in; round-section flexure is independent of unbraced length.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 90.4,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 90.41666666666667,
                    "difference": 0.01666666666666572,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 81.4,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 81.375,
                    "difference": 0.025000000000005684,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 54.1,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 54.14171656686627,
                    "difference": 0.041716566866270455,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "shearLengthIn": 240,
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.9B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.09B-pipe-flexure-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 8.625,
                "bf": 8.625,
                "tdes": 0.465,
                "tnom": 0.5,
                "Sx": 23.1,
                "Zx": 31,
                "ry": 2.89,
                "J": 199,
                "Ix": 100,
                "A": 11.9,
                "W": 43.4
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "not applicable",
                "summary": "Compact wall"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A53 Grade B",
                "Fy": 35,
                "Fu": 60
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-RECT-SHEAR",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · two-wall shear",
            "section": "HSS6X4X3/8",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G4-1",
                "G2-9"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 104,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 103.71582,
                    "difference": 0.2841800000000063,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 93.6,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.3,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 93.34423799999999,
                    "difference": 0.25576200000000426,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.3,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 62.3,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.25,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 62.10528143712575,
                    "difference": 0.19471856287425027,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.25,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 G.4 — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/G.04-rect-hss-shear.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 6,
                "bf": 4,
                "tdes": 0.349,
                "tnom": 0.375,
                "Sx": 9.43,
                "Zx": 11.9,
                "ry": 1.55,
                "J": 32.8,
                "Ix": 28.3,
                "A": 6.18,
                "W": 22.37
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-ROUND-SHEAR",
            "title": "Round HSS · shear",
            "section": "HSS16.000X0.375",
            "family": "HSS-ROUND",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G5-1",
                "G5-2a",
                "G5-2b"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Uses the example’s actual Lv = 192 in. The beam workflow conservatively uses the full member length as an upper bound for Lv. The square root in G5-2a applies to Lv/D only.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 258,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 258,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 232,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 232.20000000000002,
                    "difference": 0.20000000000001705,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 155,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.51,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 154.49101796407186,
                    "difference": 0.5089820359281418,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.51,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Length-dependent Fcr",
                    "field": "shear.FcrA",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 112,
                    "unit": "ksi",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 112.28174743311,
                    "difference": 0.2817474331099987,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Wall-dependent Fcr",
                    "field": "shear.FcrB",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 73,
                    "unit": "ksi",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.5,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 72.87033516332508,
                    "difference": 0.12966483667491957,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.5,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "shearLengthIn": 192,
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 G.5 — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/G.05-round-hss-shear.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 16,
                "bf": 16,
                "tdes": 0.349,
                "tnom": 0.375,
                "Sx": 65.7,
                "Zx": 85.5,
                "ry": 5.53,
                "J": 1050,
                "Ix": 526,
                "A": 17.2,
                "W": 62.64
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "not applicable",
                "summary": "Noncompact wall"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "ROLAND-HSS-WEB",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · noncompact flange and web",
            "section": "HSS16X8X1/4",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-B",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F7-2",
                "F7-6"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Earlier F7 equations used rounded interpolation constants. AISC 360-22 uses the limiting slenderness ratios directly; the stated tolerances allow this small edition difference and printed b/t rounding. Source compares local buckling; continuous restraint is assumed here.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 198.42,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.35,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 198.15381555609824,
                    "difference": 0.26618444390175,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.35,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 178.58,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.35,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 178.3384340004884,
                    "difference": 0.2415659995116073,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.35,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 118.81,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.35,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 118.65497937490913,
                    "difference": 0.1550206250908701,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.35,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Web local-buckling moment",
                    "field": "bending.webBuckling",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 213.83,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.15,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 213.84744003956527,
                    "difference": 0.017440039565258303,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.15,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition",
                "url": "https://pubhtml5.com/kiwk/zuji/basic/51-100",
                "edition": "2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences",
                "location": "Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 16,
                "bf": 8,
                "tdes": 0.233,
                "tnom": 0.25,
                "Sx": 46.1,
                "Zx": 56.4,
                "ry": 3.42,
                "J": 300,
                "Ix": 368,
                "A": 10.8,
                "W": 39.43
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "noncompact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · noncompact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade B (2021+)",
                "Fy": 46,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "ROLAND-ROUND-COMPACT",
            "title": "Round HSS · yielding",
            "section": "HSS14.000X0.375",
            "family": "HSS-ROUND",
            "grade": "A500-B (pre-2021 round)",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F8-1",
                "F8-2"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "The published example uses historical round Grade B, Fy = 42 ksi. It is evaluated directly by the same pure F8/G5 kernel with that material; it does not validate today’s Grade B selector (46 ksi). Only bending is compared.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 227.85,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 227.85,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 205.07,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 205.06499999999997,
                    "difference": 0.005000000000023874,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 136.44,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 136.437125748503,
                    "difference": 0.0028742514969906097,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "shearLengthIn": 240,
            "referenceMaterial": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade B, pre-2021 round",
                "Fy": 42,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition",
                "url": "https://pubhtml5.com/kiwk/zuji/basic/51-100",
                "edition": "2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences",
                "location": "Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 14,
                "bf": 14,
                "tdes": 0.349,
                "tnom": 0.375,
                "Sx": 49.8,
                "Zx": 65.1,
                "ry": 4.83,
                "J": 698,
                "Ix": 349,
                "A": 15,
                "W": 54.62
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "not applicable",
                "summary": "Compact wall"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade B, pre-2021 round",
                "Fy": 42,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "ROLAND-ROUND-NONCOMPACT",
            "title": "Round HSS · noncompact wall",
            "section": "HSS14.000X0.250",
            "family": "HSS-ROUND",
            "grade": "A500-B (pre-2021 round)",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F8-1",
                "F8-2"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "The published example uses historical round Grade B, Fy = 42 ksi. It is evaluated directly by the same pure F8/G5 kernel with that material; it does not validate today’s Grade B selector (46 ksi). Only bending is compared.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 148.14,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 148.1517125,
                    "difference": 0.01171250000001578,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 133.33,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 133.33654125,
                    "difference": 0.0065412499999979445,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 88.71,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.03,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 88.71360029940121,
                    "difference": 0.003600299401213647,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.03,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "shearLengthIn": 240,
            "referenceMaterial": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade B, pre-2021 round",
                "Fy": 42,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition",
                "url": "https://pubhtml5.com/kiwk/zuji/basic/51-100",
                "edition": "2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences",
                "location": "Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 14,
                "bf": 14,
                "tdes": 0.233,
                "tnom": 0.25,
                "Sx": 34.1,
                "Zx": 44.2,
                "ry": 4.87,
                "J": 478,
                "Ix": 239,
                "A": 10.1,
                "W": 36.75
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "not applicable",
                "summary": "Noncompact wall"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade B, pre-2021 round",
                "Fy": 42,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": false,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-S-TABLE",
            "title": "S beam · published uniform-load table",
            "section": "S8X18.4",
            "family": "S",
            "grade": "A36",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-1",
                "G2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Simply supported, continuously braced 10-ft span. Total applied uniform load = min(8 Mc/L, 2 Vc). This is the strength table, not a deflection or self-weight deduction comparison.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD total uniform load",
                    "field": "uniform.LRFD",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 35.6,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 35.64,
                    "difference": 0.03999999999999915,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD total uniform load",
                    "field": "uniform.ASD",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 23.7,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 23.7125748502994,
                    "difference": 0.012574850299401419,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "kind": "uniform-strength",
            "spanIn": 120,
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-7",
                "url": "https://16streets.com/39-B/PDF%20files/AISC_Steel_construction_manual_fourteenth_edi.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-10; unchanged F2-1 plastic strength",
                "location": "Page 3-83, S8×18.4, Fy 36 ksi, 10-ft span; total uniform load"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 8,
                "bf": 4,
                "tw": 0.271,
                "tf": 0.425,
                "kdes": 1,
                "Sx": 14.4,
                "Zx": 16.5,
                "ry": 0.827,
                "rts": 0.985,
                "ho": 7.58,
                "J": 0.335,
                "Ix": 57.5,
                "A": 5.4,
                "W": 18.4,
                "h_tw": 22.9
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A36",
                "Fy": 36,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HP12X53-LENGTHS",
            "title": "HP shape · published limiting lengths",
            "section": "HP12X53",
            "family": "HP",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-5",
                "F2-6",
                "F3-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "For noncompact flanges the Manual tabulates Lp′, where LTB strength first falls below flange-local-buckling strength, rather than raw F2 Lp. Only limiting lengths are compared; pile compression and interaction are not checked.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Manual Lp′ (F2/F3 crossover)",
                    "field": "bending.LpEffective",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 16.6,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 16.639448441062676,
                    "difference": 0.03944844106267453,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lr",
                    "field": "bending.Lr",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 31.1,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 31.132618453369815,
                    "difference": 0.03261845336981395,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC 14th edition Manual errata · Table 4-2 replacement",
                "url": "https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/aisc/publications/revisions-and-errata/errata-to-14th-ed.-manual-1st-printing.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-10; unchanged F2/F3 limiting-length equations",
                "location": "Insert P4-27, HP12×53 and HP10×57, Fy 50 ksi; Lp′ and Lr rows"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 11.8,
                "bf": 12,
                "tw": 0.435,
                "tf": 0.435,
                "kdes": 1.13,
                "Sx": 66.7,
                "Zx": 74,
                "ry": 2.86,
                "rts": 3.29,
                "ho": 11.4,
                "J": 1.12,
                "Ix": 393,
                "A": 15.5,
                "W": 53,
                "h_tw": 22.3
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HP10X57-LENGTHS",
            "title": "HP shape · published limiting lengths",
            "section": "HP10X57",
            "family": "HP",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-5",
                "F2-6",
                "F3-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "For noncompact flanges the Manual tabulates Lp′, where LTB strength first falls below flange-local-buckling strength, rather than raw F2 Lp. Only limiting lengths are compared; pile compression and interaction are not checked.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Manual Lp′ (F2/F3 crossover)",
                    "field": "bending.LpEffective",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 8.65,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 8.653892637292063,
                    "difference": 0.003892637292063128,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Lr",
                    "field": "bending.Lr",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 34.8,
                    "unit": "ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 34.822386776237096,
                    "difference": 0.022386776237098616,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC 14th edition Manual errata · Table 4-2 replacement",
                "url": "https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/aisc/publications/revisions-and-errata/errata-to-14th-ed.-manual-1st-printing.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-10; unchanged F2/F3 limiting-length equations",
                "location": "Insert P4-27, HP12×53 and HP10×57, Fy 50 ksi; Lp′ and Lr rows"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 9.99,
                "bf": 10.2,
                "tw": 0.565,
                "tf": 0.565,
                "kdes": 1.25,
                "Sx": 58.8,
                "Zx": 66.5,
                "ry": 2.45,
                "rts": 2.84,
                "ho": 9.43,
                "J": 1.97,
                "Ix": 294,
                "A": 16.7,
                "W": 57,
                "h_tw": 13.9
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "BENTLEY-MC-LTB",
            "title": "MC channel · independent software resistance",
            "section": "MC8X8.5",
            "family": "MC",
            "grade": "A36",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 60,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-2",
                "F2-8b",
                "G2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published values",
            "notes": "Uses the section properties printed by STAAD, including rounded Iy, Cw, J, Sx and Zx. Only isolated major-axis moment and shear resistance are compared. The source’s axial/biaxial interaction result is outside this workflow.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal moment",
                    "field": "bending.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 193.16,
                    "unit": "kip-in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.04,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 193.16215305366774,
                    "difference": 0.0021530536677403234,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.04,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 173.85,
                    "unit": "kip-in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.04,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 173.84593774830097,
                    "difference": 0.00406225169902541,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.04,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 115.67,
                    "unit": "kip-in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.04,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 115.6659599123759,
                    "difference": 0.0040400876241051265,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.04,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal major-axis shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 30.931,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.001,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value",
                    "actual": 30.931199999999997,
                    "difference": 0.00019999999999598117,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.001,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "properties": {
                "d": 8,
                "bf": 1.87,
                "tw": 0.179,
                "tf": 0.311,
                "kdes": 0.813,
                "Sx": 5.825,
                "Zx": 7,
                "ry": 0.4898979485566356,
                "rts": 0.61565,
                "ho": 7.69,
                "J": 0.06,
                "Ix": 23.3,
                "A": 2.5,
                "W": 8.5,
                "Iy": 0.6,
                "Cw": 8.124,
                "h_tw": 37.3
            },
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Bentley STAAD.Pro · AISC 360-22 channel verification",
                "url": "https://docs.bentley.com/LiveContent/web/STAAD.Pro%20Help-v2024/en/topics/Verification/Design%20Steel%20AISC%20360/v-stpst_AISC_360_22_C_Interaction.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22",
                "location": "Printed STAAD LRFD/ASD output: MC8×8.5 major-axis resistance only"
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A36",
                "Fy": 36,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "CALCS-M-YIELD",
            "title": "M beam · yielding",
            "section": "M6X3.7",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A992",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "F1",
                "F2-1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published value",
            "notes": "The independent reference publishes phi Fy Zx = 8.7 kip-ft. This equals the governing bending strength only for the compact, continuously braced case tested here. This does not verify reduced M-shape shear.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD available moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 8.7,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published value, rounded to 0.1 kip-ft",
                    "actual": 8.7375,
                    "difference": 0.03750000000000142,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "Calcs.app · M6×3.7 published plastic moment",
                "url": "https://calcs.app/steel/section-properties/M6X3.7",
                "edition": "AISC v16 section data; published Fy = 50 ksi, phi = 0.9 plastic-strength calculation",
                "location": "Flexural plastic moment capacity, major axis"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 5.92,
                "bf": 2,
                "tw": 0.098,
                "tf": 0.129,
                "kdes": 0.313,
                "Sx": 2.01,
                "Zx": 2.33,
                "ry": 0.398,
                "rts": 0.499,
                "ho": 5.79,
                "J": 0.0053,
                "Ix": 5.96,
                "A": 1.09,
                "W": 3.7,
                "h_tw": 54.7
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A992",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-INELASTIC-COMPONENT",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · inelastic buckling component",
            "section": "HSS10X6X3/16",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 252,
            "clauses": [
                "F7-8",
                "F7-10",
                "F7-11"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published component normalized to Cb = 1",
            "notes": "The source prints an uncapped LTB moment of 1020 kip-in. Its quarter-point ratios give Cb = 12.5/11. Dividing the uncapped value by Cb gives 897.6 kip-in at Cb = 1; this is below Mp = 900. Only the LTB component is compared here. Flange local buckling governs the complete section check.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Nominal LTB component at Cb = 1",
                    "field": "bending.lateralBuckling",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 897.6,
                    "unit": "kip-in",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.6,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Derived reference: published 1020 × 11 / 12.5",
                    "actual": 897.0493427019317,
                    "difference": 0.5506572980683586,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.6,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC v16.0 F.7B — Shi Lab reproduction",
                "url": "https://www.shitaoshi.web.illinois.edu/resources/aisc-de/F.07B-rect-hss-noncompact-flanges-direct.html",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0",
                "location": "Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 10,
                "bf": 6,
                "tdes": 0.174,
                "tnom": 0.1875,
                "Sx": 14.9,
                "Zx": 18,
                "ry": 2.52,
                "J": 73.8,
                "Ix": 74.6,
                "A": 5.37,
                "W": 19.63
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "noncompact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Noncompact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-SHEAR-INELASTIC",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · inelastic shear buckling",
            "section": "HSS8X2X1/8",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G4-1",
                "G4-2",
                "G2-10"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published table values",
            "notes": "Table 6-D, printed p. 508: major-axis shear for the 1/8-in nominal wall. Uses the published 0.116-in design thickness and two-wall shear area. The 0.05-kip allowance is half the final displayed 0.1-kip increment. No compression or combined-force results are compared.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear strength",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 43,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published major-axis shear, phiV = 0.9",
                    "actual": 43.04288992101233,
                    "difference": 0.04288992101233191,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD shear strength",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 28.6,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published major-axis shear, OmegaV = 1.67",
                    "actual": 28.637983979382792,
                    "difference": 0.03798397938279052,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC Companion v16.0, Volume 2 · Table 6-D",
                "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240409132850id_/https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 (2023)",
                "location": "Printed pp. 500 and 508 (PDF pp. 508 and 516), major-axis shear; A500 Grade C, Fy = 50 ksi",
                "retrievedFrom": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240409132850id_/https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf",
                "sha256": "b695a8698828aa9a2ab8a808dfc86811527f8bcbbe93d17d320396072578664e",
                "publisherUrl": "https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 8,
                "bf": 2,
                "tdes": 0.116,
                "tnom": 0.125,
                "Sx": 3.93,
                "Zx": 5.19,
                "ry": 0.879,
                "J": 5.3,
                "Ix": 15.7,
                "A": 2.23,
                "W": 8.16
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "noncompact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · noncompact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-HSS-SHEAR-ELASTIC",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · elastic shear buckling",
            "section": "HSS10X2X1/8",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "clauses": [
                "G4-1",
                "G4-2",
                "G2-11"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published table values",
            "notes": "Table 6-D, printed p. 500: major-axis shear for the 1/8-in nominal wall. Uses the published 0.116-in design thickness and two-wall shear area. The 0.05-kip allowance is half the final displayed 0.1-kip increment. No compression or combined-force results are compared.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear strength",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 38.2,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published major-axis shear, phiV = 0.9",
                    "actual": 38.24065826108579,
                    "difference": 0.04065826108578818,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD shear strength",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 25.4,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published major-axis shear, OmegaV = 1.67",
                    "actual": 25.442886401254686,
                    "difference": 0.042886401254687456,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC Companion v16.0, Volume 2 · Table 6-D",
                "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240409132850id_/https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf",
                "edition": "AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 (2023)",
                "location": "Printed pp. 500 and 508 (PDF pp. 508 and 516), major-axis shear; A500 Grade C, Fy = 50 ksi",
                "retrievedFrom": "https://web.archive.org/web/20240409132850id_/https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf",
                "sha256": "b695a8698828aa9a2ab8a808dfc86811527f8bcbbe93d17d320396072578664e",
                "publisherUrl": "https://www.aisc.org/globalassets/product-files-not-searched/manuals/v16.0_vol-2_design-tables.pdf"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 10,
                "bf": 2,
                "tdes": 0.116,
                "tnom": 0.125,
                "Sx": 5.7,
                "Zx": 7.65,
                "ry": 0.89,
                "J": 6.9,
                "Ix": 28.5,
                "A": 2.7,
                "W": 9.86
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "noncompact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · noncompact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-C-ELASTIC-PLOT",
            "title": "C channel · elastic lateral buckling",
            "section": "C12X30",
            "family": "C",
            "grade": "A36",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 192,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-3",
                "F2-4",
                "F2-8b"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published graph · approximate readings",
            "notes": "Table 3-11 curve read at Lb = 16 ft, beyond the open-circle Lr marker. Reference values are approximate readings of the published plot, not printed numeric capacities. Allowances are half one minor vertical grid interval: 0.375 kip-ft LRFD and 0.25 kip-ft ASD. This is a coarse independent check of elastic LTB; separate high-precision equation tests remain required. Loading through the shear center and suitable end restraint are assumed. The curve and labels were enlarged to distinguish the dashed C12x30 curve from adjacent solid MC curves; the dual graph scales are approximate.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD moment strength",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 49,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.375,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Graph reading; 0.75 kip-ft minor grid",
                    "actual": 48.847107187206724,
                    "difference": 0.15289281279327582,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.375,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD moment strength",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 32.7,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.25,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Graph reading; 0.5 kip-ft minor grid",
                    "actual": 32.49973864750947,
                    "difference": 0.20026135249053567,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.25,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-11",
                "url": "https://www.16streets.com/39-B/PDF%20files/AISC_Steel_construction_manual_fourteenth_edi.pdf#page=332",
                "edition": "AISC 360-10; unchanged F2 elastic LTB equations",
                "location": "Printed pp. 3-140–3-141 (PDF pp. 331–332), Fy = 36 ksi, Cb = 1; graph readings, not tabulated precision",
                "sha256": "a675751317f5c17e6e5076f2ba06ce97636b02db6859139d578a2526d2c8b558"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12,
                "bf": 3.17,
                "tw": 0.51,
                "tf": 0.501,
                "kdes": 1.13,
                "Sx": 27,
                "Zx": 33.8,
                "ry": 0.762,
                "rts": 1.01,
                "ho": 11.5,
                "J": 0.861,
                "Ix": 162,
                "A": 8.81,
                "W": 30,
                "Iy": 5.12,
                "Cw": 151,
                "h_tw": 19.4
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A36",
                "Fy": 36,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "AISC-MC-ELASTIC-PLOT",
            "title": "MC channel · elastic lateral buckling",
            "section": "MC10X28.5",
            "family": "MC",
            "grade": "A36",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 360,
            "clauses": [
                "F2-3",
                "F2-4",
                "F2-8b"
            ],
            "comparison": "Published graph · approximate readings",
            "notes": "Table 3-11 curve read at Lb = 30 ft, beyond the open-circle Lr marker. Reference values are approximate readings of the published plot, not printed numeric capacities. Allowances are half one minor vertical grid interval: 0.375 kip-ft LRFD and 0.25 kip-ft ASD. This is a coarse independent check of elastic LTB; separate high-precision equation tests remain required. Loading through the shear center and suitable end restraint are assumed. At 30 ft the curve crosses approximately the 36 kip-ft LRFD / 24 kip-ft ASD grid line.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD moment strength",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 36,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.375,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Graph reading; 0.75 kip-ft minor grid",
                    "actual": 36.0839569328294,
                    "difference": 0.08395693282940186,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.375,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "ASD moment strength",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "ASD",
                    "expected": 24,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.25,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Graph reading; 0.5 kip-ft minor grid",
                    "actual": 24.00795537779734,
                    "difference": 0.007955377797340901,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.25,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "evidenceType": "published",
            "reference": {
                "title": "AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-11",
                "url": "https://www.16streets.com/39-B/PDF%20files/AISC_Steel_construction_manual_fourteenth_edi.pdf#page=332",
                "edition": "AISC 360-10; unchanged F2 elastic LTB equations",
                "location": "Printed pp. 3-140–3-141 (PDF pp. 331–332), Fy = 36 ksi, Cb = 1; graph readings, not tabulated precision",
                "sha256": "a675751317f5c17e6e5076f2ba06ce97636b02db6859139d578a2526d2c8b558"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 10,
                "bf": 3.95,
                "tw": 0.425,
                "tf": 0.575,
                "kdes": 1.31,
                "Sx": 25.3,
                "Zx": 30,
                "ry": 1.16,
                "rts": 1.36,
                "ho": 9.43,
                "J": 0.791,
                "Ix": 126,
                "A": 8.37,
                "W": 28.5,
                "Iy": 11.3,
                "Cw": 193,
                "h_tw": 17.1
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A36",
                "Fy": 36,
                "Fu": 58
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "JULIA-HSS-ELASTIC",
            "title": "Rectangular HSS · elastic lateral buckling",
            "section": "HSS12X2X3/16",
            "family": "HSS-RECT",
            "grade": "A500-C",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 1032,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "F7-9",
                "F1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · published test value",
            "notes": "The independent AISCSteel.jl test publishes 27.5 kip-ft at Lb = 86 ft, Fy = 50 ksi and Cb = 1. Our elastic-LTB result governs and Lb exceeds Lr. The source labels its expectation “not fully verified”; this is supplemental software evidence, not an authoritative worked example. The source uses pre-errata F7-11 numbering for the equation now labeled F7-9. This comparison reads the published test value; it does not claim a local run of Julia.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "LRFD moment",
                    "field": "bending.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 27.5,
                    "unit": "kip-ft",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 0.05,
                    "relativeTolerance": 0,
                    "basis": "Published test expectation; half the 0.1 kip-ft rounding increment",
                    "actual": 27.515354208123252,
                    "difference": 0.015354208123252278,
                    "allowedDifference": 0.05,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "Cole Miller · AISCSteel.jl published HSS test",
                "url": "https://github.com/co1emi11er2/AISCSteel.jl/blob/c07f8927cf4134cfb9c1b7fa345f15d6c8d309e1/test/Flexure/HSS_Shapes.jl#L45-L51",
                "edition": "AISCSteel.jl 0.2.9 · AISC Manual 16th edition",
                "location": "HSS12x2x3/16 at 86 ft; published LRFD test expectation",
                "commit": "c07f8927cf4134cfb9c1b7fa345f15d6c8d309e1",
                "gitBlob": "8ddb292a74af24dab56abc833194b3dbb5595e17"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12,
                "bf": 2,
                "tdes": 0.174,
                "tnom": 0.1875,
                "Sx": 11.2,
                "Zx": 15.5,
                "ry": 0.872,
                "J": 12,
                "Ix": 67.4,
                "A": 4.67,
                "W": 17.08
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "noncompact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · noncompact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A500 Grade C (2021+)",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 62
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M10X7_5",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M10X7.5",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.8622217257206533,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.8622217257206533,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 33.59302065580237,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 33.59302065580237,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 30.233718590222132,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 30.233718590222132,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 9.99,
                "bf": 2.69,
                "tw": 0.13,
                "tf": 0.173,
                "kdes": 0.438,
                "Sx": 6.6,
                "Zx": 7.77,
                "ry": 0.503,
                "rts": 0.646,
                "ho": 9.82,
                "J": 0.0187,
                "Ix": 33,
                "A": 2.22,
                "W": 7.5,
                "h_tw": 71
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M10X8",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M10X8",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.9418114234794828,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.9418114234794828,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 39.6394300971162,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 39.639430097116204,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 35.675487087404576,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 35.67548708740458,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 9.95,
                "bf": 2.69,
                "tw": 0.141,
                "tf": 0.182,
                "kdes": 0.563,
                "Sx": 6.95,
                "Zx": 8.2,
                "ry": 0.5,
                "rts": 0.646,
                "ho": 9.77,
                "J": 0.0224,
                "Ix": 34.6,
                "A": 2.37,
                "W": 8,
                "h_tw": 65
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M12X10",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M12X10",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.8195146255176222,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.8195146255176222,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 43.95876451276525,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 43.958764512765256,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 39.56288806148873,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 39.562888061488735,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12,
                "bf": 3.25,
                "tw": 0.149,
                "tf": 0.18,
                "kdes": 0.5,
                "Sx": 10.3,
                "Zx": 12.2,
                "ry": 0.592,
                "rts": 0.768,
                "ho": 11.8,
                "J": 0.0292,
                "Ix": 61.7,
                "A": 2.95,
                "W": 10,
                "h_tw": 74.7
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M12X10_8",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M12X10.8",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.8846494584706124,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.8846494584706124,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 50.95580880790727,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 50.955808807907275,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 45.86022792711654,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 45.86022792711655,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12,
                "bf": 3.07,
                "tw": 0.16,
                "tf": 0.21,
                "kdes": 0.563,
                "Sx": 11.1,
                "Zx": 13.2,
                "ry": 0.564,
                "rts": 0.732,
                "ho": 11.8,
                "J": 0.0393,
                "Ix": 66.7,
                "A": 3.18,
                "W": 10.8,
                "h_tw": 69.2
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M12_5X11_6",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M12.5X11.6",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.8184190177294971,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.8184190177294971,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 47.57060540552702,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 47.57060540552702,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 42.81354486497432,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 42.81354486497432,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12.5,
                "bf": 3.5,
                "tw": 0.155,
                "tf": 0.211,
                "kdes": 0.563,
                "Sx": 12.8,
                "Zx": 15,
                "ry": 0.667,
                "rts": 0.852,
                "ho": 12.3,
                "J": 0.0414,
                "Ix": 80.3,
                "A": 3.4,
                "W": 11.6,
                "h_tw": 74.8
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M12X11_8",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M12X11.8",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.9794838804186621,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.9794838804186621,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 62.41271286027714,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 62.412712860277146,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 56.17144157424943,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 56.171441574249435,
                    "difference": 7.105427357601002e-15,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12,
                "bf": 3.07,
                "tw": 0.177,
                "tf": 0.225,
                "kdes": 0.563,
                "Sx": 12,
                "Zx": 14.3,
                "ry": 0.559,
                "rts": 0.731,
                "ho": 11.8,
                "J": 0.05,
                "Ix": 72.2,
                "A": 3.47,
                "W": 11.8,
                "h_tw": 62.5
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        },
        {
            "id": "XC-G2-M12_5X12_4",
            "title": "M-section · reduced web shear",
            "section": "M12.5X12.4",
            "family": "M",
            "grade": "A572-50",
            "unbracedLengthIn": 0,
            "evidenceType": "software",
            "clauses": [
                "G2-1",
                "G2-4",
                "G1"
            ],
            "comparison": "Independent software · isolated routines",
            "notes": "XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.",
            "checks": [
                {
                    "label": "Web shear coefficient",
                    "field": "shear.Cv1",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 0.8184190177294971,
                    "unit": "",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 0.8184190177294971,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "Nominal shear",
                    "field": "shear.nominal",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 47.57060540552702,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 47.57060540552702,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                },
                {
                    "label": "LRFD shear",
                    "field": "shear.available",
                    "method": "LRFD",
                    "expected": 42.81354486497432,
                    "unit": "kip",
                    "absoluteTolerance": 1.0e-10,
                    "relativeTolerance": 1.0e-12,
                    "basis": "Frozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines",
                    "actual": 42.81354486497432,
                    "difference": 0,
                    "allowedDifference": 1.0e-10,
                    "status": "passed"
                }
            ],
            "reference": {
                "title": "XC · independent rolled-I shear routines",
                "url": "https://github.com/xcfem/xc/blob/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py#L995-L1067",
                "edition": "AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22",
                "location": "Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness",
                "commit": "2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4",
                "sha256": "2e220ccd9acc57fd009c33edd7b1e4beed2eb57eeb30ba568de73b40b95e3255",
                "sourceUrl": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/xcfem/xc/2716e7142a2956fcf70ddfef34ea2c7389eb28e4/python_modules/materials/sections/structural_shapes/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "reproduction": "python3 tools/verify-aisc-xc-shear.py /path/to/pinned/aisc_metric_shapes.py",
                "resultsFile": "tests/fixtures/aisc-xc-shear-results.json"
            },
            "properties": {
                "d": 12.5,
                "bf": 3.75,
                "tw": 0.155,
                "tf": 0.228,
                "kdes": 0.563,
                "Sx": 14.2,
                "Zx": 16.5,
                "ry": 0.744,
                "rts": 0.933,
                "ho": 12.3,
                "J": 0.0493,
                "Ix": 89.3,
                "A": 3.63,
                "W": 12.4,
                "h_tw": 74.8
            },
            "classification": {
                "flange": "compact",
                "web": "compact",
                "summary": "Compact flange · compact web"
            },
            "material": {
                "name": "ASTM A572 Grade 50",
                "Fy": 50,
                "Fu": 65
            },
            "lateralBucklingApplicable": true,
            "status": "passed"
        }
    ]
}
