Analysis & design evidence

Structural Verification Centre

Compare published steel design examples and analytical solver benchmarks with Optimal Beam results. Explore the references, numerical differences and limits of each check.

Current evidence scope AISC rolled-beam, channel, HSS and pipe design comparisons, analytical beam, bar, release and coordinate-transformation cases, and worked portal frame, gable portal frame, Pratt truss, Howe truss and Warren truss benchmarks. Additional mixed-model and browser evidence will be added as those suites are completed.

Design reference comparisons

Steel beam design · AISC 360-22

41 cases · 116 comparisons passed
Reference values checked against the current design engine.

Beam Calculator checks bending and shear strength for a single, uniform AISC catalog section in major-axis bending, using LRFD or ASD. Live- and total-load deflection checks use the project limits you enter.

Expand a benchmark to see the exact inputs and results, or see Coverage & limits below for supported models and checks that need separate review.

Published examples and tables · 33 cases

Compact section · yielding W18X50 · A992 · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 F.1-1B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Nominal and available flexural strength

Section
W18X50 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 421 kip-ft 420.833333 kip-ft 0.166667 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 379 kip-ft 378.75 kip-ft 0.25 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 252 kip-ft 251.996008 kip-ft 0.003992 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
18
bf
7.5
tw
0.355
tf
0.57
kdes
0.972
Sx
88.9
Zx
101
ry
1.65
rts
1.98
ho
17.4
J
1.24
Ix
800
A
14.7
W
50

Clauses: B4.1b · F1 · F2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Inelastic lateral-torsional buckling W18X50 · A992 · Published values normalized to Cb = 1 · 3 passed

SCIA AISC 360-22 — F.1-2B ↗
AISC 360-22 · Page 2: quarter-point moments and nominal LTB resistance

Section
W18X50 · A992
Lateral restraint
Lb = 140 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

The source uses Cb > 1. Its uncapped LTB strength is divided by Cb from the printed quarter-point moments. Available strengths then use F1 factors. The 0.2% tolerance accommodates rounded properties and the source E = 29,007.5 ksi versus our 29,000 ksi. This does not verify a variable-Cb implementation.

Published Mn: 341.59 kip-ft. Source Cb: 1.016258. Reference below = published Mn / Cb, with the stated LRFD or ASD factor.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal moment at Cb = 1Published Mn divided by source Cb 336.125381 kip-ft 335.996854 kip-ft 0.128527 kip-ft ±0.672251 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available moment at Cb = 10.90 × normalized published Mn 302.512842 kip-ft 302.397168 kip-ft 0.115674 kip-ft ±0.605026 kip-ft Pass
ASD available moment at Cb = 1Normalized published Mn / 1.67 201.272683 kip-ft 201.195721 kip-ft 0.076962 kip-ft ±0.402545 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
18
bf
7.5
tw
0.355
tf
0.57
kdes
0.972
Sx
88.9
Zx
101
ry
1.65
rts
1.98
ho
17.4
J
1.24
Ix
800
A
14.7
W
50

Clauses: F1 · F2-2 · F2-5 · F2-6. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Elastic lateral-torsional buckling W18X50 · A992 · Published values normalized to Cb = 1 · 3 passed

SCIA AISC 360-22 — F.1-3B ↗
AISC 360-22 · Page 2: quarter-point moments and nominal LTB resistance

Section
W18X50 · A992
Lateral restraint
Lb = 210 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

The source uses Cb > 1. Its uncapped LTB strength is divided by Cb from the printed quarter-point moments. Available strengths then use F1 factors. The 0.2% tolerance accommodates rounded properties and the source E = 29,007.5 ksi versus our 29,000 ksi. This does not verify a variable-Cb implementation.

Published Mn: 322.69 kip-ft. Source Cb: 1.310282. Reference below = published Mn / Cb, with the stated LRFD or ASD factor.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal moment at Cb = 1Published Mn divided by source Cb 246.275303 kip-ft 246.015465 kip-ft 0.259838 kip-ft ±0.492551 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available moment at Cb = 10.90 × normalized published Mn 221.647772 kip-ft 221.413919 kip-ft 0.233854 kip-ft ±0.443296 kip-ft Pass
ASD available moment at Cb = 1Normalized published Mn / 1.67 147.470241 kip-ft 147.31465 kip-ft 0.155591 kip-ft ±0.29494 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
18
bf
7.5
tw
0.355
tf
0.57
kdes
0.972
Sx
88.9
Zx
101
ry
1.65
rts
1.98
ho
17.4
J
1.24
Ix
800
A
14.7
W
50

Clauses: F1 · F2-3 / F2-4 · F2-5 · F2-6. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Noncompact flange · local buckling W21X48 · A992 · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 F.3B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Flange classification and F3-1 resistance

Section
W21X48 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Noncompact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 442 kip-ft 442.16777 kip-ft 0.16777 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 398 kip-ft 397.950993 kip-ft 0.049007 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 265 kip-ft 264.77112 kip-ft 0.22888 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
20.6
bf
8.14
tw
0.35
tf
0.43
kdes
0.93
Sx
93
Zx
107
ry
1.66
rts
2.05
ho
20.2
J
0.803
Ix
959
A
14.1
W
48

Clauses: B4.1b · F1 · F3-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Shear · special rolled-shape factors W24X62 · A992 · Published values · 5 passed

AISC v16.0 G.1B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Web area, nominal shear and LRFD/ASD strengths

Section
W24X62 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web areaPublished value 10.2 in² 10.191 in² 0.009 in² ±0.05 in² Pass
Nominal shearPublished value 306 kip 305.73 kip 0.27 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
LRFD available shearPublished value 306 kip 305.73 kip 0.27 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
ASD available shearPublished value 204 kip 203.82 kip 0.18 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
Shear coefficient Cv1Published value 1 1 0 ±0 Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
23.7
bf
7.04
tw
0.43
tf
0.59
kdes
1.09
Sx
131
Zx
153
ry
1.38
rts
1.75
ho
23.1
J
1.71
Ix
1550
A
18.2
W
62

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-2 · G2.1(a). Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Shear · ordinary resistance factors W24X55 · A992 · Earlier-edition published shear values · 2 passed

Veríssimo, Fakury & Ribeiro — Engineering Journal, 2006 ↗
Earlier LRFD edition (1999); matching unperforated-web shear calculation only · Printed pp. 166–167, Example 2: baseline shear strength before openings

Section
W24X55 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Only the unperforated steel-web baseline is compared: Fy = 50 ksi, d = 23.6 in, tw = 0.395 in and phiV = 0.90. Composite bending and web-opening design in the paper are not supported or verified. ASD = Vn / 1.67 is covered by code-factor and boundary tests, not a published ASD value in this source.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal web shearPublished value 280 kip 279.66 kip 0.34 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
LRFD available shearPublished value 252 kip 251.694 kip 0.306 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
23.6
bf
7.01
tw
0.395
tf
0.505
kdes
1.01
Sx
114
Zx
134
ry
1.34
rts
1.72
ho
23.1
J
1.18
Ix
1350
A
16.2
W
55

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-3 · G2.1(b). Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Service load · deflection criterion W18X50 · A992 · Published demand and service criterion · 4 passed

AISC v16.0 F.1-1A — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · 35-ft span: required moments and live-load deflection criterion

Section
W18X50 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

The published required Ix = 746 in⁴ uses the rounded 1.17 in limit. Exact L/360 gives 748.46444 in⁴; the 3 in⁴ tolerance records that rounding difference. Required Ix is derived from the actual integrated deflection, not a second beam formula. Equilibrium reactions for this simple span are supplied analytically; this case verifies integration and the criterion, not the external solver or all support arrangements.

Simply supported · 35 ft · Dead 0.45 kip/ft · Live 0.75 kip/ft · Live deflection L/360

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD required momentPublished value 266 kip-ft 266.4375 kip-ft 0.4375 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
ASD required momentPublished value 184 kip-ft 183.75 kip-ft 0.25 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Live deflection limitPublished value 1.17 in 1.166667 in 0.003333 in ±0.005 in Pass
Required moment of inertiaPublished rounded L/360 criterion 746 in⁴ 748.46444 in⁴ 2.46444 in⁴ ±3 in⁴ Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
18
bf
7.5
tw
0.355
tf
0.57
kdes
0.972
Sx
88.9
Zx
101
ry
1.65
rts
1.98
ho
17.4
J
1.24
Ix
800
A
14.7
W
50

Clauses: Elastic beam integration · Project L/360 criterion. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Yielding · A572 Grade 50 W14X68 · A572-50 · Published values · earlier edition · 2 passed

William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4 ↗
2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared · Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c

Section
W14X68 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 479.2 kip-ft 479.166667 kip-ft 0.033333 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 431 kip-ft 431.25 kip-ft 0.25 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
14
bf
10
tw
0.415
tf
0.72
kdes
1.31
Sx
103
Zx
115
ry
2.46
rts
2.8
ho
13.3
J
3.01
Ix
722
A
20
W
68

Clauses: F1 · F2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Inelastic lateral-torsional buckling · A572 Grade 50 W14X68 · A572-50 · Published values · earlier edition · 2 passed

William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4 ↗
2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared · Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c

Section
W14X68 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Lb = 240 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 381 kip-ft 380.930592 kip-ft 0.069408 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 343 kip-ft 342.837533 kip-ft 0.162467 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
14
bf
10
tw
0.415
tf
0.72
kdes
1.31
Sx
103
Zx
115
ry
2.46
rts
2.8
ho
13.3
J
3.01
Ix
722
A
20
W
68

Clauses: F1 · F2-2. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Elastic lateral-torsional buckling · A572 Grade 50 W14X68 · A572-50 · Published values · earlier edition · 2 passed

William T. Segui · Steel Design, 6th edition, Example 5.4 ↗
2018 textbook / AISC 360-16; unchanged F2 equations compared · Printed pp. 202–204 (PDF pp. 18–20), parts a–c

Section
W14X68 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Lb = 360 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Direct Cb = 1 comparison using current catalog rts = 2.80 in and ho = 13.3 in; the book calculates 2.799 and 13.28. Its ASD answers approximate 1/1.67 as 0.6, so they are not used as exact ASD references.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 291 kip-ft 290.96422 kip-ft 0.03578 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 262 kip-ft 261.867798 kip-ft 0.132202 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
14
bf
10
tw
0.415
tf
0.72
kdes
1.31
Sx
103
Zx
115
ry
2.46
rts
2.8
ho
13.3
J
3.01
Ix
722
A
20
W
68

Clauses: F1 · F2-3 / F2-4. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Yielding · A36 W8X28 · A36 · Published value · earlier edition · 1 passed

Standard Handbook of Engineering Calculations · McGraw-Hill, 2004 ↗
Earlier AISC LRFD edition; matching major-axis plastic strength only · Printed p. 1.58 (PDF p. 59), W8×28 strong-axis flexural strength; procedure by Abraham J. Rokach

Section
W8X28 · A36
Lateral restraint
Lb = 72 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Compares only the published major-axis plastic flexural resistance at Lb = 6 ft. The source also checks tension–bending interaction and other orientations; those checks are not included here. The earlier-edition reference uses the same 0.90 Fy Zx resistance.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD available momentPublished value 73.4 kip-ft 73.44 kip-ft 0.04 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 36 ksi

d
8.06
bf
6.54
tw
0.285
tf
0.465
kdes
0.859
Sx
24.3
Zx
27.2
ry
1.62
rts
1.84
ho
7.6
J
0.537
Ix
98
A
8.25
W
28

Clauses: F1 · F2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Channel · yielding C15X33.9 · A992 · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 F.2-1B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
C15X33.9 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 212 kip-ft 211.666667 kip-ft 0.333333 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 191 kip-ft 190.5 kip-ft 0.5 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 127 kip-ft 126.746507 kip-ft 0.253493 kip-ft ±0.5 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
15
bf
3.4
tw
0.4
tf
0.65
kdes
1.44
Sx
42
Zx
50.8
ry
0.901
rts
1.13
ho
14.4
J
1.01
Ix
315
A
10
W
33.9
Iy
8.07
Cw
358
h_tw
30.9

Clauses: F2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Channel · inelastic buckling C15X33.9 · A992 · Published values · 5 passed

AISC v16.0 F.2-2B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
C15X33.9 · A992
Lateral restraint
Lb = 60 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

The source rounds limiting lengths and intermediate moments. A 0.5% strength tolerance retains those published values.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 192 kip-ft 191.470334 kip-ft 0.529666 kip-ft ±0.96 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 173 kip-ft 172.323301 kip-ft 0.676699 kip-ft ±0.865 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 115 kip-ft 114.652895 kip-ft 0.347105 kip-ft ±0.575 kip-ft Pass
LpPublished value 3.18 ft 3.182513 ft 0.002513 ft ±0.01 ft Pass
LrPublished value 11.2 ft 11.206705 ft 0.006705 ft ±0.06 ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
15
bf
3.4
tw
0.4
tf
0.65
kdes
1.44
Sx
42
Zx
50.8
ry
0.901
rts
1.13
ho
14.4
J
1.01
Ix
315
A
10
W
33.9
Iy
8.07
Cw
358
h_tw
30.9

Clauses: F2-2 · F2-5 · F2-6 · F2-8b. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Channel · shear factors C15X33.9 · A992 · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 G.2B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
C15X33.9 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal shearPublished value 180 kip 180 kip 0 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
LRFD available shearPublished value 162 kip 162 kip 0 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
ASD available shearPublished value 108 kip 107.784431 kip 0.215569 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
15
bf
3.4
tw
0.4
tf
0.65
kdes
1.44
Sx
42
Zx
50.8
ry
0.901
rts
1.13
ho
14.4
J
1.01
Ix
315
A
10
W
33.9
Iy
8.07
Cw
358
h_tw
30.9

Clauses: G2-1 · G2.1(b). Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Square HSS · strength and serviceability HSS3-1/2X3-1/2X1/8 · A500-C · Published values · 4 passed

AISC v16.0 F.6 — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS3-1/2X3-1/2X1/8 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Noncompact flange · compact web

At the published design thickness, b/t lies just above the compact limit. The engine includes the small noncompact-flange reduction reflected in the published table strengths. Square HSS has no lateral-torsional buckling check.

Simply supported · 7.5 ft · Dead 0.145 kip/ft · Live 0.435 kip/ft · Live deflection L/240

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD available momentPublished value 7.2 kip-ft 7.207584 kip-ft 0.007584 kip-ft ±0.01 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 4.79 kip-ft 4.795465 kip-ft 0.005465 kip-ft ±0.01 kip-ft Pass
Required IxPublished value 2.85 in^4 2.847656 in^4 0.002344 in^4 ±0.005 in^4 Pass
Live deflection limitPublished value 0.375 in 0.375 in 0 in ±0.0005 in Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
3.5
bf
3.5
tdes
0.116
tnom
0.125
Sx
1.66
Zx
1.93
ry
1.37
J
4.58
Ix
2.9
A
1.54
W
5.61

Clauses: F7-1 · F7-2. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · noncompact flange HSS10X6X3/16 · A500-C · Published values · 5 passed

AISC v16.0 F.7B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS10X6X3/16 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Lb = 252 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Noncompact flange · compact web

The source uses Cb = 1.14; the engine uses Cb = 1. Local buckling governs in both. This comparison verifies the governing strength, not the source’s Cb-enhanced LTB value.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 66.3 kip-ft 66.361961 kip-ft 0.061961 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 59.7 kip-ft 59.725765 kip-ft 0.025765 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 39.7 kip-ft 39.737701 kip-ft 0.037701 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
LpPublished limiting length 210 in 210.142892 in 0.142892 in ±0.5 in Pass
LrPublished limiting length 5580 in 5579.426301 in 0.573699 in ±5 in Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
10
bf
6
tdes
0.174
tnom
0.1875
Sx
14.9
Zx
18
ry
2.52
J
73.8
Ix
74.6
A
5.37
W
19.63

Clauses: F7-2 · F7-10 · F7-11. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Square HSS · slender flange HSS8X8X3/16 · A500-C · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 F.8B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS8X8X3/16 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Slender flange · compact web

Uses the Companion’s conservative effective section with ineffective strips removed from both flanges. It deliberately does not claim the higher capacity obtained by shifting the neutral axis.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 50.4 kip-ft 50.307262 kip-ft 0.092738 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 45.4 kip-ft 45.276536 kip-ft 0.123464 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 30.2 kip-ft 30.124109 kip-ft 0.075891 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
8
bf
8
tdes
0.174
tnom
0.1875
Sx
13.6
Zx
15.7
ry
3.18
J
84.5
Ix
54.4
A
5.37
W
19.63

Clauses: F7-3 · F7-4. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Pipe · yielding Pipe8XS · A53-B · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 F.9B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
Pipe8XS · A53-B
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Compact wall

Flexure only is compared. The unused shear calculation takes Lv = 240 in; round-section flexure is independent of unbraced length.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 90.4 kip-ft 90.416667 kip-ft 0.016667 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 81.4 kip-ft 81.375 kip-ft 0.025 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 54.1 kip-ft 54.141717 kip-ft 0.041717 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 35 ksi

d
8.625
bf
8.625
tdes
0.465
tnom
0.5
Sx
23.1
Zx
31
ry
2.89
J
199
Ix
100
A
11.9
W
43.4

Clauses: F8-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · two-wall shear HSS6X4X3/8 · A500-C · Published values · 3 passed

AISC v16.0 G.4 — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS6X4X3/8 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal shearPublished value 104 kip 103.71582 kip 0.28418 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
LRFD available shearPublished value 93.6 kip 93.344238 kip 0.255762 kip ±0.3 kip Pass
ASD available shearPublished value 62.3 kip 62.105281 kip 0.194719 kip ±0.25 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
6
bf
4
tdes
0.349
tnom
0.375
Sx
9.43
Zx
11.9
ry
1.55
J
32.8
Ix
28.3
A
6.18
W
22.37

Clauses: G4-1 · G2-9. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Round HSS · shear HSS16.000X0.375 · A500-C · Published values · 5 passed

AISC v16.0 G.5 — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS16.000X0.375 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Noncompact wall

Uses the example’s actual Lv = 192 in. The beam workflow conservatively uses the full member length as an upper bound for Lv. The square root in G5-2a applies to Lv/D only.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal shearPublished value 258 kip 258 kip 0 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
LRFD available shearPublished value 232 kip 232.2 kip 0.2 kip ±0.5 kip Pass
ASD available shearPublished value 155 kip 154.491018 kip 0.508982 kip ±0.51 kip Pass
Length-dependent FcrPublished value 112 ksi 112.281747 ksi 0.281747 ksi ±0.5 ksi Pass
Wall-dependent FcrPublished value 73 ksi 72.870335 ksi 0.129665 ksi ±0.5 ksi Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
16
bf
16
tdes
0.349
tnom
0.375
Sx
65.7
Zx
85.5
ry
5.53
J
1050
Ix
526
A
17.2
W
62.64

Clauses: G5-1 · G5-2a · G5-2b. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · noncompact flange and web HSS16X8X1/4 · A500-B · Published values · 4 passed

Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition ↗
2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences · Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9

Section
HSS16X8X1/4 · A500-B
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Noncompact flange · noncompact web

Earlier F7 equations used rounded interpolation constants. AISC 360-22 uses the limiting slenderness ratios directly; the stated tolerances allow this small edition difference and printed b/t rounding. Source compares local buckling; continuous restraint is assumed here.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 198.42 kip-ft 198.153816 kip-ft 0.266184 kip-ft ±0.35 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 178.58 kip-ft 178.338434 kip-ft 0.241566 kip-ft ±0.35 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 118.81 kip-ft 118.654979 kip-ft 0.155021 kip-ft ±0.35 kip-ft Pass
Web local-buckling momentPublished value 213.83 kip-ft 213.84744 kip-ft 0.01744 kip-ft ±0.15 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 46 ksi

d
16
bf
8
tdes
0.233
tnom
0.25
Sx
46.1
Zx
56.4
ry
3.42
J
300
Ix
368
A
10.8
W
39.43

Clauses: F7-2 · F7-6. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Round HSS · yielding HSS14.000X0.375 · A500-B (pre-2021 round) · Published values · 3 passed

Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition ↗
2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences · Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9

Section
HSS14.000X0.375 · A500-B (pre-2021 round)
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Compact wall

The published example uses historical round Grade B, Fy = 42 ksi. It is evaluated directly by the same pure F8/G5 kernel with that material; it does not validate today’s Grade B selector (46 ksi). Only bending is compared.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 227.85 kip-ft 227.85 kip-ft 0 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 205.07 kip-ft 205.065 kip-ft 0.005 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 136.44 kip-ft 136.437126 kip-ft 0.002874 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 42 ksi

d
14
bf
14
tdes
0.349
tnom
0.375
Sx
49.8
Zx
65.1
ry
4.83
J
698
Ix
349
A
15
W
54.62

Clauses: F8-1 · F8-2. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Round HSS · noncompact wall HSS14.000X0.250 · A500-B (pre-2021 round) · Published values · 3 passed

Frederick S. Roland · Steel Design for the Civil PE and Structural SE Exams, 2nd edition ↗
2015 textbook / AISC 360-10; isolated resistance comparisons with stated edition differences · Printed pp. 5-29–5-33, Examples 5.7–5.9

Section
HSS14.000X0.250 · A500-B (pre-2021 round)
Lateral restraint
LTB not applicable
Classification
Noncompact wall

The published example uses historical round Grade B, Fy = 42 ksi. It is evaluated directly by the same pure F8/G5 kernel with that material; it does not validate today’s Grade B selector (46 ksi). Only bending is compared.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 148.14 kip-ft 148.151713 kip-ft 0.011713 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 133.33 kip-ft 133.336541 kip-ft 0.006541 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 88.71 kip-ft 88.7136 kip-ft 0.0036 kip-ft ±0.03 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 42 ksi

d
14
bf
14
tdes
0.233
tnom
0.25
Sx
34.1
Zx
44.2
ry
4.87
J
478
Ix
239
A
10.1
W
36.75

Clauses: F8-1 · F8-2. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

S beam · published uniform-load table S8X18.4 · A36 · Published values · 2 passed

AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-7 ↗
AISC 360-10; unchanged F2-1 plastic strength · Page 3-83, S8×18.4, Fy 36 ksi, 10-ft span; total uniform load

Section
S8X18.4 · A36
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Simply supported, continuously braced 10-ft span. Total applied uniform load = min(8 Mc/L, 2 Vc). This is the strength table, not a deflection or self-weight deduction comparison.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD total uniform loadPublished value 35.6 kip 35.64 kip 0.04 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
ASD total uniform loadPublished value 23.7 kip 23.712575 kip 0.012575 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 36 ksi

d
8
bf
4
tw
0.271
tf
0.425
kdes
1
Sx
14.4
Zx
16.5
ry
0.827
rts
0.985
ho
7.58
J
0.335
Ix
57.5
A
5.4
W
18.4
h_tw
22.9

Clauses: F2-1 · G2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

HP shape · published limiting lengths HP12X53 · A992 · Published values · 2 passed

AISC 14th edition Manual errata · Table 4-2 replacement ↗
AISC 360-10; unchanged F2/F3 limiting-length equations · Insert P4-27, HP12×53 and HP10×57, Fy 50 ksi; Lp′ and Lr rows

Section
HP12X53 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Noncompact flange · compact web

For noncompact flanges the Manual tabulates Lp′, where LTB strength first falls below flange-local-buckling strength, rather than raw F2 Lp. Only limiting lengths are compared; pile compression and interaction are not checked.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Manual Lp′ (F2/F3 crossover)Published value 16.6 ft 16.639448 ft 0.039448 ft ±0.05 ft Pass
LrPublished value 31.1 ft 31.132618 ft 0.032618 ft ±0.05 ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
11.8
bf
12
tw
0.435
tf
0.435
kdes
1.13
Sx
66.7
Zx
74
ry
2.86
rts
3.29
ho
11.4
J
1.12
Ix
393
A
15.5
W
53
h_tw
22.3

Clauses: F2-5 · F2-6 · F3-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

HP shape · published limiting lengths HP10X57 · A992 · Published values · 2 passed

AISC 14th edition Manual errata · Table 4-2 replacement ↗
AISC 360-10; unchanged F2/F3 limiting-length equations · Insert P4-27, HP12×53 and HP10×57, Fy 50 ksi; Lp′ and Lr rows

Section
HP10X57 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

For noncompact flanges the Manual tabulates Lp′, where LTB strength first falls below flange-local-buckling strength, rather than raw F2 Lp. Only limiting lengths are compared; pile compression and interaction are not checked.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Manual Lp′ (F2/F3 crossover)Published value 8.65 ft 8.653893 ft 0.003893 ft ±0.05 ft Pass
LrPublished value 34.8 ft 34.822387 ft 0.022387 ft ±0.05 ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
9.99
bf
10.2
tw
0.565
tf
0.565
kdes
1.25
Sx
58.8
Zx
66.5
ry
2.45
rts
2.84
ho
9.43
J
1.97
Ix
294
A
16.7
W
57
h_tw
13.9

Clauses: F2-5 · F2-6 · F3-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

MC channel · independent software resistance MC8X8.5 · A36 · Published values · 4 passed

Bentley STAAD.Pro · AISC 360-22 channel verification ↗
AISC 360-22 · Printed STAAD LRFD/ASD output: MC8×8.5 major-axis resistance only

Section
MC8X8.5 · A36
Lateral restraint
Lb = 60 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Uses the section properties printed by STAAD, including rounded Iy, Cw, J, Sx and Zx. Only isolated major-axis moment and shear resistance are compared. The source’s axial/biaxial interaction result is outside this workflow.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal momentPublished value 193.16 kip-in 193.162153 kip-in 0.002153 kip-in ±0.04 kip-in Pass
LRFD available momentPublished value 173.85 kip-in 173.845938 kip-in 0.004062 kip-in ±0.04 kip-in Pass
ASD available momentPublished value 115.67 kip-in 115.66596 kip-in 0.00404 kip-in ±0.04 kip-in Pass
Nominal major-axis shearPublished value 30.931 kip 30.9312 kip 0.0002 kip ±0.001 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 36 ksi

d
8
bf
1.87
tw
0.179
tf
0.311
kdes
0.813
Sx
5.825
Zx
7
ry
0.48989795
rts
0.61565
ho
7.69
J
0.06
Ix
23.3
A
2.5
W
8.5
Iy
0.6
Cw
8.124
h_tw
37.3

Clauses: F2-2 · F2-8b · G2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M beam · yielding M6X3.7 · A992 · Published value · 1 passed

Calcs.app · M6×3.7 published plastic moment ↗
AISC v16 section data; published Fy = 50 ksi, phi = 0.9 plastic-strength calculation · Flexural plastic moment capacity, major axis

Section
M6X3.7 · A992
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

The independent reference publishes phi Fy Zx = 8.7 kip-ft. This equals the governing bending strength only for the compact, continuously braced case tested here. This does not verify reduced M-shape shear.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD available momentPublished value, rounded to 0.1 kip-ft 8.7 kip-ft 8.7375 kip-ft 0.0375 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
5.92
bf
2
tw
0.098
tf
0.129
kdes
0.313
Sx
2.01
Zx
2.33
ry
0.398
rts
0.499
ho
5.79
J
0.0053
Ix
5.96
A
1.09
W
3.7
h_tw
54.7

Clauses: F1 · F2-1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · inelastic buckling component HSS10X6X3/16 · A500-C · Published component normalized to Cb = 1 · 1 passed

AISC v16.0 F.7B — Shi Lab reproduction ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 · Published nominal and LRFD/ASD strengths; see example calculation

Section
HSS10X6X3/16 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Lb = 252 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Noncompact flange · compact web

The source prints an uncapped LTB moment of 1020 kip-in. Its quarter-point ratios give Cb = 12.5/11. Dividing the uncapped value by Cb gives 897.6 kip-in at Cb = 1; this is below Mp = 900. Only the LTB component is compared here. Flange local buckling governs the complete section check.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Nominal LTB component at Cb = 1Derived reference: published 1020 × 11 / 12.5 897.6 kip-in 897.049343 kip-in 0.550657 kip-in ±0.6 kip-in Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
10
bf
6
tdes
0.174
tnom
0.1875
Sx
14.9
Zx
18
ry
2.52
J
73.8
Ix
74.6
A
5.37
W
19.63

Clauses: F7-8 · F7-10 · F7-11. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · inelastic shear buckling HSS8X2X1/8 · A500-C · Published table values · 2 passed

AISC Companion v16.0, Volume 2 · Table 6-D ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 (2023) · Printed pp. 500 and 508 (PDF pp. 508 and 516), major-axis shear; A500 Grade C, Fy = 50 ksi

Section
HSS8X2X1/8 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · noncompact web

Table 6-D, printed p. 508: major-axis shear for the 1/8-in nominal wall. Uses the published 0.116-in design thickness and two-wall shear area. The 0.05-kip allowance is half the final displayed 0.1-kip increment. No compression or combined-force results are compared.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD shear strengthPublished major-axis shear, phiV = 0.9 43 kip 43.04289 kip 0.04289 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
ASD shear strengthPublished major-axis shear, OmegaV = 1.67 28.6 kip 28.637984 kip 0.037984 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
8
bf
2
tdes
0.116
tnom
0.125
Sx
3.93
Zx
5.19
ry
0.879
J
5.3
Ix
15.7
A
2.23
W
8.16

Clauses: G4-1 · G4-2 · G2-10. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Rectangular HSS · elastic shear buckling HSS10X2X1/8 · A500-C · Published table values · 2 passed

AISC Companion v16.0, Volume 2 · Table 6-D ↗
AISC 360-22 / Companion v16.0 (2023) · Printed pp. 500 and 508 (PDF pp. 508 and 516), major-axis shear; A500 Grade C, Fy = 50 ksi

Section
HSS10X2X1/8 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · noncompact web

Table 6-D, printed p. 500: major-axis shear for the 1/8-in nominal wall. Uses the published 0.116-in design thickness and two-wall shear area. The 0.05-kip allowance is half the final displayed 0.1-kip increment. No compression or combined-force results are compared.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD shear strengthPublished major-axis shear, phiV = 0.9 38.2 kip 38.240658 kip 0.040658 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
ASD shear strengthPublished major-axis shear, OmegaV = 1.67 25.4 kip 25.442886 kip 0.042886 kip ±0.05 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
10
bf
2
tdes
0.116
tnom
0.125
Sx
5.7
Zx
7.65
ry
0.89
J
6.9
Ix
28.5
A
2.7
W
9.86

Clauses: G4-1 · G4-2 · G2-11. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

C channel · elastic lateral buckling C12X30 · A36 · Published graph · approximate readings · 2 passed

AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-11 ↗
AISC 360-10; unchanged F2 elastic LTB equations · Printed pp. 3-140–3-141 (PDF pp. 331–332), Fy = 36 ksi, Cb = 1; graph readings, not tabulated precision

Section
C12X30 · A36
Lateral restraint
Lb = 192 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Table 3-11 curve read at Lb = 16 ft, beyond the open-circle Lr marker. Reference values are approximate readings of the published plot, not printed numeric capacities. Allowances are half one minor vertical grid interval: 0.375 kip-ft LRFD and 0.25 kip-ft ASD. This is a coarse independent check of elastic LTB; separate high-precision equation tests remain required. Loading through the shear center and suitable end restraint are assumed. The curve and labels were enlarged to distinguish the dashed C12x30 curve from adjacent solid MC curves; the dual graph scales are approximate.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD moment strengthGraph reading; 0.75 kip-ft minor grid 49 kip-ft 48.847107 kip-ft 0.152893 kip-ft ±0.375 kip-ft Pass
ASD moment strengthGraph reading; 0.5 kip-ft minor grid 32.7 kip-ft 32.499739 kip-ft 0.200261 kip-ft ±0.25 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 36 ksi

d
12
bf
3.17
tw
0.51
tf
0.501
kdes
1.13
Sx
27
Zx
33.8
ry
0.762
rts
1.01
ho
11.5
J
0.861
Ix
162
A
8.81
W
30
Iy
5.12
Cw
151
h_tw
19.4

Clauses: F2-3 · F2-4 · F2-8b. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

MC channel · elastic lateral buckling MC10X28.5 · A36 · Published graph · approximate readings · 2 passed

AISC Steel Construction Manual, 14th edition · Table 3-11 ↗
AISC 360-10; unchanged F2 elastic LTB equations · Printed pp. 3-140–3-141 (PDF pp. 331–332), Fy = 36 ksi, Cb = 1; graph readings, not tabulated precision

Section
MC10X28.5 · A36
Lateral restraint
Lb = 360 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

Table 3-11 curve read at Lb = 30 ft, beyond the open-circle Lr marker. Reference values are approximate readings of the published plot, not printed numeric capacities. Allowances are half one minor vertical grid interval: 0.375 kip-ft LRFD and 0.25 kip-ft ASD. This is a coarse independent check of elastic LTB; separate high-precision equation tests remain required. Loading through the shear center and suitable end restraint are assumed. At 30 ft the curve crosses approximately the 36 kip-ft LRFD / 24 kip-ft ASD grid line.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD moment strengthGraph reading; 0.75 kip-ft minor grid 36 kip-ft 36.083957 kip-ft 0.083957 kip-ft ±0.375 kip-ft Pass
ASD moment strengthGraph reading; 0.5 kip-ft minor grid 24 kip-ft 24.007955 kip-ft 0.007955 kip-ft ±0.25 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 36 ksi

d
10
bf
3.95
tw
0.425
tf
0.575
kdes
1.31
Sx
25.3
Zx
30
ry
1.16
rts
1.36
ho
9.43
J
0.791
Ix
126
A
8.37
W
28.5
Iy
11.3
Cw
193
h_tw
17.1

Clauses: F2-3 · F2-4 · F2-8b. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Supplemental software comparisons · 8 cases

Separate implementations provide additional checks. These do not replace published worked examples or engineering review.

Rectangular HSS · elastic lateral buckling HSS12X2X3/16 · A500-C · Independent software · published test value · 1 passed

Cole Miller · AISCSteel.jl published HSS test ↗
AISCSteel.jl 0.2.9 · AISC Manual 16th edition · HSS12x2x3/16 at 86 ft; published LRFD test expectation

Section
HSS12X2X3/16 · A500-C
Lateral restraint
Lb = 1032 in · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · noncompact web

The independent AISCSteel.jl test publishes 27.5 kip-ft at Lb = 86 ft, Fy = 50 ksi and Cb = 1. Our elastic-LTB result governs and Lb exceeds Lr. The source labels its expectation “not fully verified”; this is supplemental software evidence, not an authoritative worked example. The source uses pre-errata F7-11 numbering for the equation now labeled F7-9. This comparison reads the published test value; it does not claim a local run of Julia.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
LRFD momentPublished test expectation; half the 0.1 kip-ft rounding increment 27.5 kip-ft 27.515354 kip-ft 0.015354 kip-ft ±0.05 kip-ft Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12
bf
2
tdes
0.174
tnom
0.1875
Sx
11.2
Zx
15.5
ry
0.872
J
12
Ix
67.4
A
4.67
W
17.08

Clauses: F7-9 · F1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M10X7.5 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M10X7.5 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.862222 0.862222 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 33.593021 kip 33.593021 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 30.233719 kip 30.233719 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
9.99
bf
2.69
tw
0.13
tf
0.173
kdes
0.438
Sx
6.6
Zx
7.77
ry
0.503
rts
0.646
ho
9.82
J
0.0187
Ix
33
A
2.22
W
7.5
h_tw
71

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M10X8 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M10X8 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.941811 0.941811 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 39.63943 kip 39.63943 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 35.675487 kip 35.675487 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
9.95
bf
2.69
tw
0.141
tf
0.182
kdes
0.563
Sx
6.95
Zx
8.2
ry
0.5
rts
0.646
ho
9.77
J
0.0224
Ix
34.6
A
2.37
W
8
h_tw
65

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M12X10 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M12X10 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.819515 0.819515 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 43.958765 kip 43.958765 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 39.562888 kip 39.562888 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12
bf
3.25
tw
0.149
tf
0.18
kdes
0.5
Sx
10.3
Zx
12.2
ry
0.592
rts
0.768
ho
11.8
J
0.0292
Ix
61.7
A
2.95
W
10
h_tw
74.7

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M12X10.8 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M12X10.8 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.884649 0.884649 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 50.955809 kip 50.955809 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 45.860228 kip 45.860228 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12
bf
3.07
tw
0.16
tf
0.21
kdes
0.563
Sx
11.1
Zx
13.2
ry
0.564
rts
0.732
ho
11.8
J
0.0393
Ix
66.7
A
3.18
W
10.8
h_tw
69.2

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M12.5X11.6 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M12.5X11.6 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.818419 0.818419 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 47.570605 kip 47.570605 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 42.813545 kip 42.813545 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12.5
bf
3.5
tw
0.155
tf
0.211
kdes
0.563
Sx
12.8
Zx
15
ry
0.667
rts
0.852
ho
12.3
J
0.0414
Ix
80.3
A
3.4
W
11.6
h_tw
74.8

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M12X11.8 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M12X11.8 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.979484 0.979484 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 62.412713 kip 62.412713 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 56.171442 kip 56.171442 kip 7.105e-15 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12
bf
3.07
tw
0.177
tf
0.225
kdes
0.563
Sx
12
Zx
14.3
ry
0.559
rts
0.731
ho
11.8
J
0.05
Ix
72.2
A
3.47
W
11.8
h_tw
62.5

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

M-section · reduced web shear M12.5X12.4 · A572-50 · Independent software · isolated routines · 3 passed

XC · independent rolled-I shear routines ↗
AISC 360-16 G2-1/G2-4 · unchanged equations in 360-22 · Original isolated routines, executed with supplied v16 M-section properties; reproducible local harness

Section
M12.5X12.4 · A572-50
Lateral restraint
Continuous · Cb = 1
Classification
Compact flange · compact web

XC’s original rolled-I routines are executed without formula changes, using supplied catalog d, tw and h/tw, E = 29,000 ksi and Fy = 50 ksi. Unstiffened kv = 5.34 and ordinary LRFD factors apply. This compares the isolated shear calculation; it is not a published worked example, a full XC model run or an independent catalog check. ASD factors are covered by separate equation tests.

Scroll the table to see all values →

Checked resultReferenceCalculatedDifferenceToleranceStatus
Web shear coefficientFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 0.818419 0.818419 0 ±1.000e-10 Pass
Nominal shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 47.570605 kip 47.570605 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
LRFD shearFrozen output from unmodified, version-pinned XC routines 42.813545 kip 42.813545 kip 0 kip ±1.000e-10 kip Pass
Section properties & references

Canonical inch–kip units · E = 29,000 ksi · Fy = 50 ksi

d
12.5
bf
3.75
tw
0.155
tf
0.228
kdes
0.563
Sx
14.2
Zx
16.5
ry
0.744
rts
0.933
ho
12.3
J
0.0493
Ix
89.3
A
3.63
W
12.4
h_tw
74.8

Clauses: G2-1 · G2-4 · G1. Dimensions in inches; Sx/Zx in in³, Ix/Iy/J in in⁴, Cw in in⁶, A in in², W in lb/ft; h_tw is dimensionless. Each tolerance is the larger of its absolute allowance and its relative allowance × |reference|. Exact inputs and tolerances are in the downloadable evidence.

Coverage & limits

Major-axis beam checks cover W, S, M and HP shapes with compact webs; compact C and MC channels; square and rectangular HSS; round HSS and pipe. Each case above identifies the exact quantity compared. HP comparisons cover limiting lengths; they do not verify pile compression.

Supported beam models use linear elastic analysis with pins, rollers, fixed ends, or linear vertical and rotational springs. Loads may be point forces, applied moments, or linearly varying distributed loads. The gravity preset covers dead and live loads. Enter project-specific combinations and any required load patterns.

Review compression-flange restraint and support torsional restraint for your model. Lateral-torsional buckling checks use Cb = 1 where applicable. Channels require explicit confirmation of loading and torsional restraint. Axial force, minor-axis bending, torsion, connection design, bearing, web crippling and brace adequacy need separate checks.

Published comparisons cover yielding, rolled/channel lateral buckling, HSS noncompact and slender flanges, HSS noncompact webs, round-wall local buckling, all three rectangular-HSS shear regimes and serviceability. The two channel elastic-buckling comparisons use approximate graph readings; their tolerances reflect the source grid. Slender HSS flanges use the conservative method in Companion F.8B.

Supplemental software comparisons cover reduced shear for all seven affected M sections and rectangular-HSS elastic lateral buckling. The M checks run isolated XC routines with supplied catalog properties. The HSS reference is a published AISCSteel.jl test marked “not fully verified” by its author. Authoritative worked examples for these two branches are still sought.

Separate equation and boundary tests cover synthetic slender sections; these tests are not counted as published benchmarks.

These are representative comparisons, not verification of every model or full AISC compliance. Earlier-edition references apply only to the stated matching equations. The serviceability cases check integration with known equilibrium reactions; they are not independent tests of the external beam solver.

How the evidence is produced

Reference first. Optimal Beam Solver second.

Expected answers are established independently using closed-form structural mechanics. The Optimal Beam Solver then analyzes the same model, and every declared output is evaluated against a tolerance chosen before the test runs.

  1. 01

    Define the reference

    Geometry, properties, loads, equations and expected answers are recorded without using an Optimal Beam Solver result as the source.

  2. 02

    Run the real solver

    The benchmark runner imports the same solver file delivered to calculator users. There is no separate demonstration calculator.

  3. 03

    Apply declared tolerances

    Each numerical check records its expected value, displayed engineering unit, absolute tolerance and relative tolerance.

  4. 04

    Publish generated evidence

    This page reads the resulting evidence artifact. Counts and calculated values are not maintained as a second handwritten copy.

Numerical acceptance rule

|calculated − expected| ≤ absolute tolerance + relative tolerance × |expected|

For these well-conditioned closed-form cases, the default relative tolerance is 1e-8 and the relative equilibrium residual must not exceed 1e-10. Case-specific near-zero tolerances are shown in each result table.

Current benchmark record

Every current case, equation and checked result

16 reproducible models · 142 declared checks · generated July 31, 2026 · 9:53 PM EDT

Axial response

1 case
OB-V-BAR-001 Horizontal axial bar with end force 5/5 checks passed · closed-form · residual 0

Reference basis

Uniform prismatic bar fixed at one end and loaded axially at the other.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_x = -P delta = P L / (E A) N = P
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction -100 kN -100 kN 0 kN ±1.010e-6 kN Pass
Node N2 · Horizontal displacement 0.3 mm 0.3 mm 5.551e-17 mm ±1.300e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute axial force 100 kN 100 kN 0 kN ±1.010e-6 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 0 kN m 0 kN m 0 kN m ±1.000e-9 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 0 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • axial stiffness
  • nodal force
  • reaction
  • axial displacement

Cantilever response

3 cases
OB-V-BEAM-001 Cantilever with transverse tip force 5/5 checks passed · closed-form · residual 4.547e-16

Reference basis

Prismatic cantilever with a vertical point force at the free end.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_y = P M_root = P L delta_tip = P L^3 / (3 E I)
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 10 kN 10 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±1.100e-7 kN Pass
Node N1 · Support moment 40 kN m 40 kN m 3.553e-14 kN m ±4.100e-7 kN m Pass
Node N2 · Vertical displacement -5.33333333 mm -5.33333333 mm 2.665e-15 mm ±6.333e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 40 kN m 40 kN m 3.553e-14 kN m ±4.100e-7 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 4.547e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • flexural stiffness
  • nodal force
  • reaction
  • tip displacement
  • peak moment
OB-V-BEAM-002 Cantilever with applied tip moment 6/6 checks passed · closed-form · residual 5.457e-16

Reference basis

Prismatic cantilever with a positive moment applied at the free end.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
M_root = -M theta_tip = M L / (E I) delta_tip = M L^2 / (2 E I)
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Support moment -10 kN m -10 kN m 1.066e-14 kN m ±1.100e-7 kN m Pass
Node N2 · Vertical displacement 2 mm 2 mm 1.332e-15 mm ±3.000e-8 mm Pass
Node N2 · Rotation 0.001 rad 0.001 rad 6.505e-19 rad ±1.001e-8 rad Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 10 kN m 10 kN m 0 kN m ±1.100e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 0 kN 0 kN 0 kN ±1.000e-9 kN Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 5.457e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • nodal moment
  • rotation
  • curvature
  • constant moment
OB-V-BEAM-009 Cantilever with full uniform load 9/9 checks passed · closed-form · residual 2.339e-16

Reference basis

Four metre prismatic cantilever with a ten kilonewton-per-metre uniform load.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_y = w L = 40 kN M_root = w L^2 / 2 = 80 kN m theta_tip = -w L^3 / (6 E I) = -0.002666666667 rad delta_tip = -w L^4 / (8 E I) = -8 mm
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 40 kN 40 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±4.100e-7 kN Pass
Node N1 · Support moment 80 kN m 80 kN m 4.263e-14 kN m ±8.100e-7 kN m Pass
Node N2 · Vertical displacement -8 mm -8 mm 5.329e-15 mm ±9.000e-8 mm Pass
Node N2 · Rotation -0.00266667 rad -0.00266667 rad 2.168e-18 rad ±1.003e-8 rad Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement 8 mm 8 mm 7.105e-15 mm ±9.000e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement location 4 m 4 m 0 m ±5.000e-8 m Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 40 kN 40 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±4.100e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 80 kN m 80 kN m 4.263e-14 kN m ±8.100e-7 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 2.339e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • distributed load
  • cantilever reaction
  • tip rotation
  • tip displacement

Simply supported response

9 cases
OB-V-BEAM-003 Simply supported beam with full uniform load 8/8 checks passed · closed-form · residual 3.638e-16

Reference basis

Six metre simply supported prismatic beam with a ten kilonewton-per-metre uniform load.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_A = R_B = w L / 2 V_max = w L / 2 M_max = w L^2 / 8 delta_max = 5 w L^4 / (384 E I)
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 30 kN 30 kN 0 kN ±3.100e-7 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 30 kN 30 kN 3.553e-15 kN ±3.100e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 30 kN 30 kN 0 kN ±3.100e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 45 kN m 45 kN m 1.421e-14 kN m ±4.600e-7 kN m Pass
Model · Maximum displacement 4.21875 mm 4.21875 mm 0 mm ±5.219e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Start-end moment 0 kN m 1.091e-14 kN m 1.091e-14 kN m ±1.000e-8 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Finish-end moment 0 kN m 1.091e-14 kN m 1.091e-14 kN m ±1.000e-8 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 3.638e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • distributed load
  • released rotations
  • reactions
  • shear
  • moment
  • member displacement
OB-V-BEAM-005 Simply supported beam with triangular distributed load 6/6 checks passed · closed-form · residual 2.165e-16

Reference basis

Six metre simply supported beam with a triangular load increasing from zero to twelve kilonewtons per metre.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_A = w_max L / 6 = 12 kN R_B = w_max L / 3 = 24 kN V(x) = 12 - x^2 x_Mmax = sqrt(12) = 3.464101615 m M_max = 16 sqrt(3) = 27.712812921 kN m
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 12 kN 12 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±1.300e-7 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 24 kN 24 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 27.71281292 kN m 27.71281292 kN m 1.421e-14 kN m ±2.871e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Peak moment location 3.46410162 m 3.46410162 m 2.147e-12 m ±4.464e-8 m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 2.165e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • linearly varying load
  • asymmetric reactions
  • off-grid critical moment
  • critical-station recovery
OB-V-BEAM-006 Simply supported beam with off-centre point load 7/7 checks passed · closed-form · residual 2.046e-16

Reference basis

Six metre simply supported beam with a ten kilonewton point load two metres from the left support.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_A = P b / L = 6.666666667 kN R_B = P a / L = 3.333333333 kN M_max = P a b / L = 13.333333333 kN m x_delta,max = L - sqrt((L^2 - a^2) / 3) = 2.734013676 m delta_max = 0.967699651 mm
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 6.66666667 kN 6.66666667 kN 0 kN ±7.667e-8 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 3.33333333 kN 3.33333333 kN 0 kN ±4.333e-8 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 13.33333333 kN m 13.33333333 kN m 1.776e-15 kN m ±1.433e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Peak moment location 2 m 2 m 0 m ±3.000e-8 m Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement 0.96769965 mm 0.96769965 mm 4.441e-16 mm ±1.968e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement location 2.73401368 m 2.73401368 m 8.002e-13 m ±3.734e-8 m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 2.046e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • member point load
  • asymmetric reactions
  • point-load moment
  • off-grid displacement maximum
OB-V-BEAM-007 Simply supported beam with partial uniform load 6/6 checks passed · closed-form · residual 1.001e-16

Reference basis

Six metre simply supported beam with an eight kilonewton-per-metre load from x = 1 m to x = 4 m.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
W = 24 kN at x = 2.5 m R_A = 14 kN R_B = 10 kN V(x) = 14 - 8(x - 1) within the loaded interval x_Mmax = 2.75 m M_max = 26.25 kN m
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 14 kN 14 kN 1.776e-15 kN ±1.500e-7 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 10 kN 10 kN 0 kN ±1.100e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 14 kN 14 kN 1.776e-15 kN ±1.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 26.25 kN m 26.25 kN m 0 kN m ±2.725e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Peak moment location 2.75 m 2.75 m 4.441e-14 m ±3.750e-8 m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 1.001e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • partial distributed load
  • load boundaries
  • off-grid critical moment
OB-V-TRUSS-001 Four-panel Pratt truss under symmetric joint loading 12/12 checks passed · hand-calculation · residual 2.910e-11

Reference basis

Statically determinate four-panel Pratt truss checked by whole-structure equilibrium, the method of joints, the method of sections and the unit-load method.

Nodes
8
Members
13
Loads
3
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
m + r = 2j: 13 + 3 = 2(8) R_Ay = R_By = 3(16) / 2 = 24 kN M7 = -24 / sin(45 degrees) = -33.941125497 kN M9 = (24 - 16) / sin(45 degrees) = 11.313708499 kN delta_N7 = sum(N_i n_i L_i / EA) = 0.655529004 mm downward
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 0 kN 2.910e-14 kN 2.910e-14 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 2.132e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Node N5 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M5 · Axial -32 kN -32 kN 0 kN ±3.300e-7 kN Pass
Member M7 · Axial -33.9411255 kN -33.9411255 kN 4.263e-14 kN ±3.494e-7 kN Pass
Member M8 · Axial 0 kN 0 kN 0 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M9 · Axial 11.3137085 kN 11.3137085 kN 3.553e-15 kN ±1.231e-7 kN Pass
Member M12 · Axial 0 kN 0 kN 0 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N7 · Vertical displacement -0.655529 mm -0.655529 mm 0 mm ±1.656e-8 mm Pass
Model · Maximum displacement 0.6711589 mm 0.6711589 mm 0 mm ±1.671e-8 mm Pass
Solver · Stability classification stable stable — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 2.910e-11 7.090e-11 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • axial-only members
  • support reactions
  • zero-force members
  • member force
  • nodal displacement
OB-V-TRUSS-002 Four-panel Warren truss under symmetric joint loading 13/13 checks passed · hand-calculation · residual 7.276e-11

Reference basis

Statically determinate four-panel Warren truss checked by whole-structure equilibrium, symmetry, the method of joints, the method of sections and the unit-load method.

Nodes
9
Members
15
Loads
4
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
m + r = 2j: 15 + 3 = 2(9) R_Ay = R_By = 4(12) / 2 = 24 kN M8 = -24 / sin(63.434949 degrees) = -26.832815730 kN M10 = -(24 - 12) / sin(63.434949 degrees) = -13.416407865 kN M11 = M12 = 0 kN by symmetry and vertical equilibrium at N3 delta_N3 = sum(N_i n_i L_i / EA) = 0.453246118 mm downward
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 0 kN 7.276e-14 kN 7.276e-14 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 3.553e-15 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Node N5 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 3.908e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M2 · Axial 24 kN 24 kN 8.171e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M5 · Axial -18 kN -18 kN 2.842e-14 kN ±1.900e-7 kN Pass
Member M8 · Axial -26.83281573 kN -26.83281573 kN 0 kN ±2.783e-7 kN Pass
Member M10 · Axial -13.41640786 kN -13.41640786 kN 0 kN ±1.442e-7 kN Pass
Member M11 · Axial 0 kN 5.821e-14 kN 5.821e-14 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M12 · Axial 0 kN -1.455e-14 kN 1.455e-14 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N3 · Vertical displacement -0.45324612 mm -0.45324612 mm 0 mm ±1.453e-8 mm Pass
Model · Maximum displacement 0.46593566 mm 0.46593566 mm 0 mm ±1.466e-8 mm Pass
Solver · Stability classification stable stable — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 7.276e-11 2.724e-11 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • axial-only members
  • support reactions
  • alternating diagonal forces
  • zero-force members
  • nodal displacement
OB-V-TRUSS-003 Four-panel Howe truss under symmetric joint loading 13/13 checks passed · hand-calculation · residual 5.093e-11

Reference basis

Statically determinate four-panel Howe truss checked by whole-structure equilibrium, the method of joints, the method of sections and the unit-load method.

Nodes
8
Members
13
Loads
3
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
m + r = 2j: 13 + 3 = 2(8) R_Ay = R_By = 3(16) / 2 = 24 kN M7 = -24 / sin(45 degrees) = -33.941125497 kN M9 = -(24 - 16) / sin(45 degrees) = -11.313708499 kN M10 = 0 kN by the zero-force member rule at N3 delta_N7 = sum(N_i n_i L_i / EA) = 0.631529004 mm downward
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 0 kN 5.093e-14 kN 5.093e-14 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 3.197e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Node N5 · Vertical reaction 24 kN 24 kN 4.974e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M2 · Axial 32 kN 32 kN 6.750e-14 kN ±3.300e-7 kN Pass
Member M5 · Axial -24 kN -24 kN 5.684e-14 kN ±2.500e-7 kN Pass
Member M7 · Axial -33.9411255 kN -33.9411255 kN 0 kN ±3.494e-7 kN Pass
Member M8 · Axial 8 kN 8 kN 2.931e-14 kN ±9.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M9 · Axial -11.3137085 kN -11.3137085 kN 0 kN ±1.231e-7 kN Pass
Member M10 · Axial 0 kN 0 kN 0 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N7 · Vertical displacement -0.631529 mm -0.631529 mm 0 mm ±1.632e-8 mm Pass
Model · Maximum displacement 0.65349283 mm 0.65349283 mm 0 mm ±1.653e-8 mm Pass
Solver · Stability classification stable stable — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 5.093e-11 4.907e-11 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • axial-only members
  • support reactions
  • compression diagonals
  • zero-force member
  • nodal displacement
OB-V-FRAME-001 Fixed-base portal frame under roof and lateral loading 14/14 checks passed · direct-stiffness-and-equilibrium · residual 2.676e-16

Reference basis

Six metre by four metre fixed-base portal frame checked using an independently assembled six-degree-of-freedom stiffness equation, member-force recovery and whole-frame equilibrium.

Nodes
4
Members
3
Loads
2
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
D_s = 3m + r - 3j = 3(3) + 6 - 3(4) = 3 [K_ff]{d_f} = {F_f} sum(F_x) = 0: 0.742689154 - 12.742689154 + 12 = 0 kN sum(F_y) = 0: 20.811337467 + 27.188662533 - 48 = 0 kN u_2 = 1.289030548 mm and theta_2 = -0.000694027884 rad
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 0.74268915 kN 0.74268915 kN 0 kN ±1.743e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 20.81133747 kN 20.81133747 kN 0 kN ±2.181e-7 kN Pass
Node N1 · Support moment 5.45490053 kN m 5.45490053 kN m 8.882e-16 kN m ±6.455e-8 kN m Pass
Node N4 · Horizontal reaction -12.74268915 kN -12.74268915 kN 0 kN ±1.374e-7 kN Pass
Node N4 · Vertical reaction 27.18866253 kN 27.18866253 kN 0 kN ±2.819e-7 kN Pass
Node N4 · Support moment 23.41312427 kN m 23.41312427 kN m 0 kN m ±2.441e-7 kN m Pass
Node N2 · Horizontal displacement 1.28903055 mm 1.28903055 mm 0 mm ±2.289e-8 mm Pass
Node N2 · Rotation -0.69402788 mrad -0.69402788 mrad 1.110e-16 mrad ±1.694e-8 mrad Pass
Node N3 · Horizontal displacement 1.28457441 mm 1.28457441 mm 0 mm ±2.285e-8 mm Pass
Member M2 · Peak absolute shear force 27.18866253 kN 27.18866253 kN 0 kN ±2.819e-7 kN Pass
Member M2 · Peak absolute bending moment 27.55763235 kN m 27.55763235 kN m 0 kN m ±2.856e-7 kN m Pass
Member M3 · Axial -27.18866253 kN -27.18866253 kN 0 kN ±2.819e-7 kN Pass
Solver · Stability classification stable stable — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 2.676e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • rigid joints
  • fixed supports
  • distributed load
  • lateral load
  • frame sway
  • joint rotation
  • axial force
  • shear force
  • bending moment
OB-V-FRAME-002 Fixed-base gable portal frame with inclined rafter loading 15/15 checks passed · direct-stiffness-and-equilibrium · residual 1.348e-15

Reference basis

Eight metre fixed-base gable portal frame checked using an independently assembled nine-degree-of-freedom stiffness equation, transformed rafter load vectors, member-force recovery and whole-frame equilibrium.

Nodes
5
Members
4
Loads
3
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
D_s = 3m + r - 3j = 3(4) + 6 - 3(5) = 3 [K_ff]{d_f} = {F_f} {p'_e} = {0, qL/2, qL^2/12, 0, qL/2, -qL^2/12} sum(F_x) = 0: 5.197684844 - 5.197684844 + transformed rafter loads = 0 kN sum(F_y) = 0: 18.549752026 + 13.450247974 - 32 = 0 kN
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 5.19768484 kN 5.19768484 kN 8.882e-16 kN ±6.198e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 18.54975203 kN 18.54975203 kN 0 kN ±1.955e-7 kN Pass
Node N1 · Support moment -7.57391225 kN m -7.57391225 kN m 0 kN m ±8.574e-8 kN m Pass
Node N5 · Horizontal reaction -5.19768484 kN -5.19768484 kN 0 kN ±6.198e-8 kN Pass
Node N5 · Vertical reaction 13.45024797 kN 13.45024797 kN 0 kN ±1.445e-7 kN Pass
Node N5 · Support moment 9.97192846 kN m 9.97192846 kN m 0 kN m ±1.097e-7 kN m Pass
Node N3 · Horizontal displacement 0.2290007 mm 0.2290007 mm 0 mm ±1.229e-8 mm Pass
Node N3 · Vertical displacement -0.91911324 mm -0.91911324 mm 0 mm ±1.919e-8 mm Pass
Node N3 · Rotation 0.31618789 mrad 0.31618789 mrad 0 mrad ±1.316e-8 mrad Pass
Member M2 · Peak absolute shear force 14.26692727 kN 14.26692727 kN 0 kN ±1.527e-7 kN Pass
Member M2 · Peak absolute bending moment 13.21682713 kN m 13.21682713 kN m 0 kN m ±1.422e-7 kN m Pass
Member M4 · Axial -13.45024797 kN -13.45024797 kN 0 kN ±1.445e-7 kN Pass
Model · Maximum displacement 1.11499827 mm 1.11499827 mm 0 mm ±2.115e-8 mm Pass
Solver · Stability classification stable stable — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 1.348e-15 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • rigid joints
  • fixed supports
  • inclined members
  • local-axis distributed load
  • nodal moment
  • joint rotation
  • axial force
  • shear force
  • bending moment

Restraints and releases

2 cases
OB-V-BEAM-004 Fixed-pinned beam with full uniform load 5/5 checks passed · closed-form · residual 0

Reference basis

Six metre prismatic member fixed at the start and rotationally released at the restrained finish.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_A = 5 w L / 8 R_B = 3 w L / 8 |M_A| = w L^2 / 8 M_B = 0
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 37.5 kN 37.5 kN 7.105e-15 kN ±3.850e-7 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 22.5 kN 22.5 kN 0 kN ±2.350e-7 kN Pass
Member M1 · Start-end moment 45 kN m 45 kN m 0 kN m ±4.600e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Finish-end moment 0 kN m 0 kN m 0 kN m ±1.000e-8 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 0 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • one-end release
  • release condensation
  • reaction distribution
  • end moment
OB-V-BEAM-008 Fixed-fixed beam with full uniform load 9/9 checks passed · closed-form · residual 0

Reference basis

Six metre fixed-fixed prismatic beam with a ten kilonewton-per-metre uniform load.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_A = R_B = w L / 2 = 30 kN |M_A| = |M_B| = w L^2 / 12 = 30 kN m delta_max = w L^4 / (384 E I) = 0.84375 mm
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 30 kN 30 kN 3.553e-15 kN ±3.100e-7 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 30 kN 30 kN 0 kN ±3.100e-7 kN Pass
Node N1 · Support moment 30 kN m 30 kN m 3.553e-15 kN m ±3.100e-7 kN m Pass
Node N2 · Support moment -30 kN m -30 kN m 3.553e-15 kN m ±3.100e-7 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement 0.84375 mm 0.84375 mm 0 mm ±1.844e-8 mm Pass
Member M1 · Maximum displacement location 3 m 3 m 0 m ±4.000e-8 m Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 30 kN m 30 kN m 2.842e-14 kN m ±3.100e-7 kN m Pass
Solver · Stability classification fully-restrained fully-restrained — Exact match Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 0 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • fully restrained system
  • fixed-end forces
  • member displacement recovery

Coordinate transformations

1 case
OB-V-XFORM-001 Inclined simply supported member with global point load 9/9 checks passed · closed-form · residual 1.819e-16

Reference basis

Three-four-five inclined member with a ten kilonewton global vertical point load at midspan.

Nodes
2
Members
1
Loads
1
E
200 GPa
A
5000 mm²
I
2.0e+8 mm⁴
R_Ay = R_By = P / 2 P_local,x = -P sin(theta) = -8 kN P_local,y = -P cos(theta) = -6 kN |N|max = 4 kN |V|max = 3 kN M_max = P_local,y L / 4 = 7.5 kN m
Checked result Reference Calculated Difference Acceptance Status
Node N1 · Horizontal reaction 0 kN 0 kN 0 kN ±1.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N1 · Vertical reaction 5 kN 5 kN 0 kN ±6.000e-8 kN Pass
Node N2 · Vertical reaction 5 kN 5 kN 0 kN ±6.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute axial force 4 kN 4 kN 0 kN ±5.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute shear force 3 kN 3 kN 0 kN ±4.000e-8 kN Pass
Member M1 · Peak absolute bending moment 7.5 kN m 7.5 kN m 8.882e-16 kN m ±8.500e-8 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Start-end moment 0 kN m -9.095e-16 kN m 9.095e-16 kN m ±1.000e-8 kN m Pass
Member M1 · Finish-end moment 0 kN m 9.095e-16 kN m 9.095e-16 kN m ±1.000e-8 kN m Pass
Solver · Relative equilibrium residual 1.000e-10 1.819e-16 1.000e-10 ≤ 1.000e-10 Pass
  • inclined member
  • global member load
  • local force transformation
  • reaction transformation

Interpret the evidence correctly

Verified scope and explicit limitations

This evidence supports the documented mathematical domain. It is not a statement that every possible structure, modelling decision or real-world condition has been validated.

Covered by the solver formulation

  • First-order, linear-elastic 2D static response
  • Axial and Euler-Bernoulli flexural stiffness
  • Nodal, point and linearly varying member loads
  • Fixed, pinned, roller and custom restraints
  • Continuous, one-end-released and pin-ended members
  • Local and global member-load directions
  • Load cases, linear combinations and self-weight

Not provided by this solver

  • P-Delta or other second-order effects
  • Geometric or material nonlinearity
  • Tension-only or compression-only behavior
  • Shear deformation or support settlement
  • Thermal, buckling, modal or dynamic analysis
  • Member resistance or connection design
  • Certification of a particular engineering design
Engineering-use statement

This release passed the documented benchmark suite within the stated tolerances for first-order, linear-elastic 2D analysis. Verification does not constitute design certification or replace independent professional review of geometry, restraints, loading, assumptions and governing requirements.

Traceable release evidence

Download the evidence behind this page

The JSON package contains the exact benchmark models, reference notes, declared tolerances, calculated values, differences, diagnostics, runtime information and the Optimal Beam Solver fingerprint.

Suite
Optimal Beam priority analytical verification
Generated
July 31, 2026 · 9:53 PM EDT
Solver SHA-256
7cb2472d5ee0864d1b5c5b0db4fbbc8413c8fa13185c784403fb8591c3ebb89c
Result
Passed

Methodology references

Credibility guidance and comparison resources

These references inform the verification approach. Their inclusion does not represent certification or a claim of formal compliance.